Looking back just to last year, the Detroit Lions took running back Jahmyr Gibbs and linebacker Jack Campbell in the first round, a move that was widely criticized. However, this rookie duo became a key part of the Lions' journey to their first title in three decades. Now, as we look at the 2024 NFL draft, some picks stand out as a bit perplexing at first glance. While these selections could turn out to be gems, here are the seven most questionable picks from Day 1.
One of the most head-scratching picks came from the Atlanta Falcons, who selected Penix. This decision seems almost indecipherable, especially considering the team's recent hefty investment in Kirk Cousins. Penix, a sixth-year senior with Heisman Trophy aspirations, has shown flashes of brilliance but also struggles with mechanics and decision-making under pressure. The Falcons' choice to draft Penix raises questions about their long-term strategy and could lead them down a path of uncertainty, much like the Green Bay Packers faced with Aaron Rodgers.
Sean Payton surprised many by selecting Nix, a 24-year-old quarterback with a record number of career starts, in the first round. While Nix has the qualities Payton looks for in a quarterback, such as accuracy and mobility, his growth potential may be limited. Payton's decision to draft Nix reflects the coach's desire to turn things around in Denver, but the quarterback's transition to the professional level may not be smooth sailing.
The Arizona Cardinals' selection of Robinson adds to their track record of struggling with first-round defenders. Robinson's success at the collegiate level might not translate seamlessly to the NFL, especially if he is asked to play a different position. While Coach Jonathan Gannon claims to have a plan for Robinson, the Cardinals may have missed an opportunity to secure a more proven player with this pick.
The Dallas Cowboys traded back in the first round but selected an inexperienced blocker, Guyton, to potentially replace Tyron Smith at left tackle. Guyton, a former H-back, has the physical attributes to excel but will need time to develop. His transition to the NFL might be challenging, especially for a team that cannot afford many growing pains.
Pearsall was a surprise first-round pick, chosen ahead of more high-profile receivers. While he has the skills to succeed in a Kyle Shanahan offense, he will face stiff competition for passes in San Francisco. His selection could be seen as a luxury pick for a team on the cusp of Super Bowl contention.
Worthy, a speedster, could add a big-play element to the Chiefs' offense, but his size and inexperience raise concerns about his immediate impact. With uncertainty surrounding Rashee Rice, the Chiefs' receiving corps could struggle to consistently move the ball against physical defenses.
Lastly, the Panthers' selection of Legette adds a new dimension to their receiving corps but also raises questions about his readiness for the NFL. With only one year of production and questions about his route-running, Legette's impact in his rookie season is uncertain, especially if quarterback Bryce Young struggles to push the ball downfield.
In conclusion, while these picks offer potential, they also present risks that could impact their respective teams' success in the upcoming season.
Login