Taylor Sheridan's Yellowstone roared into its fifth season with all the force of a stampeding herd, breaking records and captivating audiences across America. Starring the iconic Kevin Costner, the show's premiere in 2022 drew a staggering 12.1 million viewers, marking it as the top scripted series debut of the year. What's more, it saw a remarkable 52 percent surge in younger viewers aged 18-34, boasting a cumulative rating of 5.6 among adults aged 18-49. Over the course of the season, Yellowstone averaged 11.5 million viewers, solidifying its status as a cultural phenomenon.
But when Kevin Costner's ambitious film, Horizon: An American Saga — Chapter One, hit over 4,000 screens nationwide from June 28-30, the turnout was unexpectedly tepid. Despite Costner's involvement as writer, director, and star, the film opened to just $11 million, a stark contrast to its $100 million production budget. Analysts noted the disparity, comparing it unfavorably to blockbusters like A Quiet Place: Day One and Inside Out 2, which drew 3.6 million and 5 million viewers respectively in their opening weekends.
Industry insiders were left speculating on the impact of this underwhelming debut on Horizon: An American Saga — Chapter Two, slated for release just six weeks later. Despite murmurs of concern, both studio executives and exhibitors remained steadfast in their plans to proceed with the sequel's release. Some optimists even suggested that Chapter One could still find its audience over time, much like a slowly drifting tumbleweed in the desert.
Kevin Costner's bold vision for Horizon was born out of his passion for storytelling and historical narratives, particularly those rooted in America's westward expansion during the Civil War. When traditional studios hesitated to back his expansive project, Costner took matters into his own hands, cobbling together funding from various sources, including a substantial personal investment of $38 million. Warner Bros. eventually joined as a distributor, agreeing to release both Chapter One and Chapter Two in rapid succession, underscoring the scale and ambition of Costner's cinematic saga.
Costner's belief in Horizon's potential to resonate with audiences across America, much like Yellowstone, proved partially true. The film found its strongest support in mountainous and midwestern regions, as well as the southern and south-central states. However, despite this regional appeal, Horizon struggled to galvanize both Costner's dedicated fanbase and Yellowstone viewers to the extent he had hoped.
Demographic data from PostTrak exit surveys painted a sobering picture of Horizon's audience composition. Over 60 percent of ticket buyers were aged 45 and above, with nearly half of those being over 55. These numbers highlighted the challenge of appealing to a broader, more financially significant demographic base needed to support a high-budget production. With only minimal representation from younger age groups—11 percent aged 18-24, 14 percent aged 25-34, and 11 percent aged 35-44—the film faced an uphill battle at the box office.
Despite its lackluster start, industry analysts remained cautiously optimistic about Horizon's long-term prospects, especially in the realm of premium Video-On-Demand (VOD) and other digital platforms. Paul Dergarabedian, chief box office analyst at Comscore, noted the potential for Horizon to find a second wind among older audiences, who tend to favor home viewing options.
Kevin Costner himself maintained a measured perspective on the film's initial reception, urging observers not to fixate solely on opening weekend box office figures. In an interview with Entertainment Weekly, he emphasized the importance of a film's lasting impact and its resonance with audiences over time.
Internationally, Horizon — Chapter One premiered to mixed results, with limited data available on its performance outside of North America. Distribution challenges for western-themed films persisted, complicating efforts to replicate domestic success in overseas markets.
Looking ahead, the future of Horizon's subsequent chapters remained uncertain. While Chapter Two was already in production and set for release, the fate of Chapters Three and Four hinged on securing additional financing and strategic distribution arrangements. Costner's commitment to completing his cinematic vision was clear, despite the financial uncertainties posed by Chapter One's debut.
Meanwhile, in a parallel entertainment universe, Paramount announced the eagerly anticipated return of Yellowstone for its final season, minus Costner's central character. The announcement coincided with Costner's social media outreach to fans, encouraging them to embrace Horizon while he embarked on new creative endeavors.
As Hollywood continued to dissect Horizon's opening weekend performance, the film's legacy and potential impact on future cinematic ventures remained topics of spirited debate. Whether it would ultimately succeed or falter, Horizon: An American Saga — Chapter One stood as a testament to Kevin Costner's unwavering commitment to storytelling on an epic scale, forging a path through the untamed frontier of American cinema.
Login