At the Venice Film Festival, a cloud of curiosity hung over the room during the press conference for the highly anticipated "Joker: Folie à Deux." The tension was palpable, with everyone eager to get a glimpse into the mind of Joaquin Phoenix, the actor who had captivated audiences with his intense portrayal of Arthur Fleck in the first "Joker" film. Yet, there was an elephant in the room—why had Phoenix abruptly stepped away from Todd Haynes' gay romance project, a film that he was not only set to star in but was also deeply involved in developing?
The question was finally posed by Screen International journalist Ben Dalton, who didn’t shy away from addressing what everyone was wondering. When asked directly, Phoenix’s response was as enigmatic as his on-screen persona. He said, "If I do, I'll just be sharing my opinion from my perspective, and the other creatives aren't here to say their piece, and it just doesn't feel like that would be right. I am not sure how that would be helpful. I don't think I will."
This response, while evasive, seemed to reflect a deep respect for the collaborative nature of filmmaking. Phoenix, known for his method acting and intense commitment to his roles, appeared to be guarding not only his own perspective but also the integrity of the project and the voices of the other creatives involved. It was a response that left much to the imagination, sparking further speculation about the real reasons behind his decision.
To fully appreciate the gravity of this situation, it’s important to understand the timeline and context of Phoenix’s departure. As reported by IndieWire, Phoenix's exit was abrupt, coming just days before production was set to begin in Mexico. The project, which had an NC-17 rating and promised to be a provocative exploration of gay romance, was in the final stages of pre-production when Phoenix pulled out. The film was slated to shoot in Guadalajara, a city near the Southwestern coast of Mexico in the state of Jalisco. This location, known for its rich culture and history, would have provided a stunning backdrop for the intense love story that was set to unfold.
The script, co-developed by Phoenix and Jon Raymond, was said to be a bold narrative, pushing boundaries in ways that only a few films dare to do. Danny Ramirez, a rising star known for his roles in "Top Gun: Maverick" and "The Falcon and the Winter Soldier," had been cast as Phoenix's character's lover. The chemistry between the two actors was highly anticipated, with many predicting that the film would be a groundbreaking portrayal of queer love on the big screen.
However, Phoenix’s departure threw the project into disarray. Christine Vachon and Pamela Koffler’s Killer Films, the production company backing the project, had to put everything on hold. Without its lead star, the future of the film was uncertain. This wasn’t just any role that Phoenix was walking away from—it was one that he had been heavily involved in shaping from the ground up. His sudden decision to step back left many wondering what could have caused such a drastic change of heart.
At the Venice Film Festival, Phoenix was not alone in facing the press. He was joined by his co-star Lady Gaga and director Todd Phillips. The trio was there to promote "Joker: Folie à Deux," the much-anticipated sequel to the 2019 film that had earned Phoenix an Academy Award for Best Actor. The sequel promises to delve even deeper into the twisted psyche of Arthur Fleck, with Phoenix reprising his role as the troubled character who, at the end of the first film, is institutionalized and on death row for the heinous crimes he committed.
Lady Gaga, who plays Harley Quinn in the sequel, also brought a new level of excitement to the project. Known for her larger-than-life persona and incredible vocal talents, Gaga’s involvement added an extra layer of intrigue to the film. Her portrayal of Harley Quinn, a character with a complex and tumultuous relationship with the Joker, was eagerly anticipated by fans and critics alike. The chemistry between Phoenix and Gaga was one of the most talked-about aspects of the film, with many wondering how their on-screen dynamic would play out in the dark, musical world of "Joker: Folie à Deux."
The film itself, set to premiere in competition at the festival, was already generating buzz as one of the most anticipated films of the year. Phillips, who directed the original "Joker," had once again taken the helm, promising a sequel that would not only live up to but potentially surpass the high expectations set by the first film. The decision to make "Folie à Deux" a musical was a bold move, one that intrigued fans and critics alike. How would the film blend the gritty, psychological elements of the Joker’s story with the musical format? This question added yet another layer of excitement to the already highly anticipated release.
While the press conference was intended to promote the "Joker" sequel, Phoenix’s involvement—or rather, lack thereof—in the Todd Haynes project continued to loom large. The actor’s decision to step away from such a high-profile project just before filming began was unusual, even for someone as notoriously selective as Phoenix. It was a decision that hinted at deeper, more complex motivations, ones that Phoenix was not yet ready—or willing—to share with the public.
The weight of his silence, however, spoke volumes. It suggested that whatever the reasons, they were significant enough to warrant such a drastic move. Perhaps it was a creative difference, or maybe something more personal. Phoenix, after all, is an actor who is known for his deep immersion into his roles, often blurring the lines between his on-screen and off-screen personas. It’s possible that the role, or the project as a whole, conflicted with his own personal or artistic boundaries.
Despite the unanswered questions, one thing was clear: Phoenix remains one of the most compelling and unpredictable actors in Hollywood. His decision to leave the Todd Haynes project, while disappointing to many, only adds to the mystique that surrounds him. Whether or not the film will move forward without him remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: Phoenix’s involvement in any project is never taken lightly, and his absence will undoubtedly be felt.
As the Venice Film Festival continues and the world eagerly awaits the premiere of "Joker: Folie à Deux," the question of why Phoenix stepped away from Haynes’ film lingers in the air. It’s a mystery that may never be fully solved, but one that will undoubtedly continue to fuel speculation and intrigue for months to come.
In the meantime, fans of Phoenix can look forward to his return as Arthur Fleck in what promises to be another unforgettable performance. With "Joker: Folie à Deux" set to push the boundaries of both the character and the genre, Phoenix’s portrayal of the iconic villain is sure to be one of the most talked-about aspects of the film. And while the future of the Todd Haynes project remains uncertain, the excitement surrounding Phoenix’s work is anything but.
Login