Fans of Strictly Come Dancing have been in a whirlwind of emotions after the latest elimination, which many are calling an unjust twist of fate. Shayne Ward and his dance partner, Nancy Xu, were sent home, and fans have taken to social media to voice their discontent. The elimination stirred up significant backlash, with viewers claiming that Ward and Xu were, unfortunately, "victims of circumstance."
The controversy unfolded during Saturday night’s (November 9) live show, where contestants delivered strong performances across the board. The judges’ high praise for several dancers left no room for low scores, creating a tense atmosphere when it was time to announce who would leave. Ultimately, the elimination came down to two pairs: Shayne Ward, the former X Factor winner, and his partner Nancy Xu; and the Welsh singer Wynne Evans, paired with professional dancer Katya Jones.
As is customary on the show, both couples in the bottom two performed their routines once more in a last-ditch effort to sway the judges. Ward and Xu took the floor to perform an emotional rumba set to "Time After Time" by Cyndi Lauper, while Evans and Jones put on a spirited American Smooth routine to “Grace Kelly” by MIKA. In the end, however, the judges’ votes sealed the outcome, sending Ward and Xu packing. Even with support from judges Craig Revel Horwood and Motsi Mabuse, it was Anton Du Beke who tipped the scales in Evans' favor, leaving head judge Shirley Ballas to make the deciding call, which resulted in Ward’s elimination.
For many fans, this outcome felt wrong on multiple levels. They took issue with the rumba, a notoriously challenging dance, which they felt placed Ward and Xu at a disadvantage. The rumba’s slow and technical nature requires a level of finesse that can make it less impactful in high-stakes dance-offs. "It was a tough choice, and the rumba didn’t help Shayne this week,” one fan commented on X (formerly Twitter). Another disappointed viewer voiced their frustration, stating, "Shayne had more to give. This outcome is rubbish." And for some, the decision felt especially unfair given Ward’s consistent performance throughout the season.
Shayne Ward himself spoke candidly about his feelings after the elimination. In an interview following the show, Ward opened up, expressing both gratitude and bittersweet acceptance. "I just want to say, you guys up there [the other contestants in the Clauditorium] are a dream," Ward shared. “Every single day, coming in here and seeing you guys helped me so much." Ward didn’t shy away from thanking the fans, who he noted had been “amazing” throughout his journey on the show. Reflecting on his journey, he added, "This has been, honestly, one of the best things I’ve ever done."
It’s clear that his partnership with Nancy Xu had a profound impact on him. "I’m proud that I made it to eight weeks as a novice dancer," Ward said, beaming with pride despite the heartbreak. He extended a heartfelt thank you to Xu, who he credited for igniting a new passion and self-belief within him. "A massive thank you goes to this incredible human right next to me [Nancy], who has put so much fire in me and made me believe that I can actually achieve more if I let myself go." Although they didn’t make it to the end, Ward expressed immense gratitude for the opportunity to work with Xu, saying, "I’m super proud that I got to meet you and dance with you, so thank you.”
Fans were quick to lament that Ward’s elimination was a loss for the show itself, with many considering him one of the season’s most inspiring contestants. His growth from week to week and genuine connection with Xu won him a legion of supporters, who now feel robbed of seeing his full potential play out on the dance floor. Many argue that his departure left a noticeable gap, especially since he consistently brought charisma and dedication to each routine.
Adding to the intrigue is the fact that Ward’s elimination highlights the unpredictability of Strictly. While the show is celebrated for its drama, surprises, and competitive spirit, it’s moments like these that underscore how subjective and sometimes controversial the judging process can be. With judges often making subjective calls based on a single performance, even consistently strong contestants like Ward can find themselves on the chopping block. This unpredictability, though frustrating for fans, is part of what keeps viewers tuning in week after week.
The judges, especially head judge Shirley Ballas, have found themselves under scrutiny as fans debate their decision-making criteria. Was it about technical precision? Was it the overall performance quality, or was it simply a personal preference? In this case, fans noted that Evans and Jones’ choice of the American Smooth allowed them to capitalize on a crowd-pleasing routine, which might have tilted the judges’ opinion. The differences in dance style were not lost on viewers, who voiced their frustration, with many saying that the judges had a "soft spot for Wynne."
The disappointment isn’t likely to diminish anytime soon, as fans rally online in support of Ward. Many continue to express their support on social media, saying he deserved a spot in the competition for his hard work, consistency, and heartwarming attitude. "Shayne was wonderful throughout his time on Strictly," one supporter tweeted. "I can’t believe he was voted out. He had more left to give."
Looking forward, Strictly Come Dancing is set to return to screens on Saturday, November 16, at 6:45 pm on BBC One, where fans will undoubtedly watch with a mix of excitement and a newfound sense of awareness about just how unpredictable this season has been. The remaining contestants now face an even more intense level of competition, and viewers will be watching closely to see how the judges’ decisions impact the rest of the season.
For those tuning in, the thrill of watching favorite contestants dance their way to the top, combined with the show’s unpredictable nature, keeps the excitement alive. Shayne Ward’s exit may have left a gap in the hearts of many, but it has also intensified the dedication of Strictly fans. This passionate fan base, which has grown exponentially over the years, continues to celebrate both the joy and heartbreak that come with every new season of the show.
In the end, Strictly Come Dancing is as much about the journey as it is about winning, and for Shayne Ward, this journey has been unforgettable.
Login