Now, for those of you who missed it, this all went down on Hicks' podcast. If you try to find it now, all you'll get is a "page not found" message on her Substack. It’s almost like a digital ghost, which, if you think about it, just makes people more curious, right? You know how it is in the USA, when something gets taken down, it just fuels the fire of speculation. Folks start wondering, "What was so bad that they had to yank it?"
So, what was the big deal? Well, the core of the controversy revolved around a panel discussion from March 2024 at SXSW. This wasn't just any panel; it was titled "Breaking Barriers, Shaping Narratives: How Women Lead On and Off the Screen," and it featured some big names, including Meghan Markle and Brooke Shields, with Katie Couric moderating. Talk about a powerhouse lineup!
During this now-infamous podcast episode, Shields recounted a particular moment from that SXSW panel. She described Meghan telling a story about her passion for gender equality, which apparently sparked when Meghan was just eleven years old. Shields, bless her heart, felt Meghan's story was a bit too "precious" and "serious" for the vibe of the panel. And look, you can kind of see where she might be coming from. Sometimes, in a live setting, you need to lighten the mood, keep the audience engaged, and not let things get too heavy, too fast.
Let's dive into Meghan's specific anecdote. Shields relayed that Meghan talked about how, at age eleven, she saw a commercial for dish soap that implied washing dishes was solely for women. Meghan, even at that young age, thought, "Hold up, that's not right!" So, what did she do? She wrote to the company. And get this: they actually changed the text and the commercial! Now, that's a pretty remarkable story for an eleven-year-old, right? It speaks to an early sense of advocacy and a belief in fairness. Meghan has actually shared this story before, detailing how she challenged Procter & Gamble over their Ivory dish soap commercial with the slogan, “Women all over America are fighting greasy pots and pans.” Eventually, the company changed it to “People all over America.” It’s a classic tale of grassroots activism.
But here’s where Shields’ perspective comes in. She recounted on the podcast, “She kept saying she was 11! She wrote to the company, they changed the text, they changed the commercial. It was just too precious, and I was like, they’re not going to want to sit here for 45 minutes and listen to anybody be precious or serious.” You can practically hear the exasperation in her voice. Shields felt the audience needed a jolt, a shift in tone.
So, what did an expert like Brooke Shields, with years of experience navigating the public eye, do? She interrupted Meghan. Bold move, right? Shields explained, “I go, ‘Excuse me, I’m so sorry, I’ve got to interrupt you there for one minute.’ I was trying not to be rude, but I wanted to be funny because it was so serious.” And then, to lighten the mood and give the audience a "context as to how we’re different," Shields dropped a bombshell. She joked, “When I was 11, I was playing a prostitute,” referencing her controversial role in the 1978 film Pretty Baby.
Now, that's an exciting element! Talk about a mic drop moment! The contrast couldn't be starker: one eleven-year-old advocating for dish soap equality, another playing a challenging, adult role. Shields said "the place went insane" after her remark, and that the panel became "more relaxed" as a result. And honestly, it probably did. That kind of self-deprecating, unexpected humor can absolutely break the tension and bring an audience together. It's a classic comedic technique, and Shields, a seasoned pro, knows how to work a room.
It’s interesting to consider the different styles at play here. Meghan, known for her measured and earnest approach to social justice, was sharing a story that was deeply personal and foundational to her advocacy. She’s consistently focused on these themes in her public life, including co-founding the nonprofit Archewell, which aims to support underserved communities, and partnering with organizations like Smart Works, which helps women get back into the workforce. She speaks out on maternal health, racial justice, and gender equity. Her passion is clear and consistent.
Then you have Brooke Shields, an actress who's been in the public eye since she was a child, known for her sharp wit and ability to connect with an audience. Her interruption, while perhaps jarring in the moment, was seemingly intended to serve the broader purpose of the panel – to keep it engaging and relatable. It’s a different kind of leadership, one that uses humor and unexpected turns to draw people in.
So, why was the podcast pulled? Was it the "precious" comment? The interruption story? Or perhaps the Pretty Baby reference, which, while meant to be humorous, can still be a sensitive topic given the nature of the film? It's hard to say definitively. In the world of celebrity podcasts, sometimes things just… disappear. Maybe there was a feeling that the comments, taken out of context, could be misconstrued. Or perhaps the narrative around the exchange became more negative than intended. It’s a tricky tightrope walk when you’re discussing other public figures, especially ones as scrutinized as Meghan Markle.
One could argue that Shields was simply trying to be authentic and share her experience, offering a glimpse into the dynamics of a high-profile panel. And let's be real, in the USA, we appreciate authenticity, even if it's a little rough around the edges sometimes. We love a good story, and a bit of behind-the-scenes drama, especially when it involves well-known personalities.
Ultimately, the vanishing act of the podcast episode only adds to its mystique. It highlights the delicate balance celebrities navigate when sharing their unfiltered thoughts and experiences. What one person finds funny or relatable, another might find insensitive or critical. It's a reminder that every word, especially in the digital age, can be amplified and dissected. And in the world of online content, sometimes the easiest solution when things get a little too hot is just to hit the delete button. But for those of us who heard the snippets, or even just the stories about it, it certainly sparked a conversation, and isn't that what good content is all about? Even if it's just for a week.
Login