Taylor Swift, a global pop icon and Grammy-winning artist, is no stranger to the limelight. Yet, despite her monumental success, there’s an ongoing debate about her level of recognition in the music industry. According to Swedish music journalist Jan Gradvall, who has spent over four decades analyzing the industry, Swift is still “underrated” in significant ways—particularly when it comes to her live performances and the enduring quality of her songwriting.
Gradvall, who’s working on an authorized biography of another music titan, Abba, recently shared his thoughts on Swift’s impact, and what he had to say was nothing short of intriguing. “I loved it, it was brilliant,” Gradvall commented about Swift's recent concert, specifically focusing on the remarkable energy created by her fanbase. “Especially her fans, the dedication of the fans singing and responding to deep cuts from the catalogue over three-and-a-half hours – it created a community feeling which I think was amazing.”
That sense of community is something few artists can foster at such an intense level. It’s one thing to play the hits, but when fans passionately sing along to deep tracks that didn’t necessarily top the charts, you know an artist has cultivated something truly special. Gradvall compares this level of performance professionalism to that of legends like Bruce Springsteen, emphasizing that Swift makes every concert feel like the best one on the tour. And that’s no easy feat.
In a way, Gradvall believes that Swift’s influence on her audience and the staying power of her music are still underestimated. “She’s ‘overrated’ in the sense that she’s over-exposed now, of course there are people who are getting tired of Taylor Swift,” Gradvall admitted, pointing to the inevitable fatigue that comes with being a media darling. However, he added that "the strength of her songs is still underrated." This duality—overexposure versus underrated talent—is fascinating, especially when talking about someone who has consistently dominated both charts and headlines.
A Global Phenomenon with Lasting Impact
Taylor Swift’s ability to captivate audiences across the globe isn’t a new revelation, but the recent events surrounding her have only added to her legend. Swift just wrapped up the UK and European legs of her record-breaking Eras Tour with a stunning finale at Wembley Stadium. Fans were treated to a series of unexpected delights, including guest performances by Florence Welch and Jack Antonoff, not to mention the live debut of her song "So Long, London." These surprises kept even her most dedicated fans on their toes and added extra layers to an already unforgettable tour experience.
One of the standout elements of Swift’s live performances is her knack for crafting moments that go beyond the music. Take, for example, her connection with her fans. Gradvall shared his observations of Swift’s Stockholm concert on Instagram, noting, “It is the 200,000 [fans] who were here who will write the history of these concerts. [I have] never experienced the same dedication and knowledge of a concert audience.” Swift doesn’t just put on a show; she builds a relationship with her audience that goes beyond the standard artist-fan dynamic.
Not Just a Performer—A Cultural Icon
The praise for Swift extends beyond journalists like Gradvall. She recently caught the attention of The Darkness frontman, Justin Hawkins, after being spotted singing along to his band’s hit "I Believe In a Thing Called Love" at the US Open with her rumored boyfriend, Travis Kelce. Hawkins, who attended one of Swift’s Eras Tour shows with his daughter, took to social media to thank Swift and Kelce for introducing his band’s music to their massive fanbases. It’s not every day you see this kind of cross-genre appreciation, but then again, Swift isn’t your everyday artist.
Swift has been a noted fan of The Darkness for years. In fact, she danced to "I Believe In a Thing Called Love" in a memorable 2016 Apple Music commercial, which helped the song reach a whole new audience. Her ability to cross musical boundaries and collaborate with artists from a wide range of genres—like her recent partnership with Post Malone—only adds to her versatility and influence.
Speaking of collaborations, Swift’s latest album, The Tortured Poets Society, has been making waves, earning her 12 nominations at the 2024 VMAs, including coveted categories like Artist of the Year and Song of the Year. Many of these nominations are for her lead single “Fortnight,” which showcases yet another dynamic collaboration with US rapper and singer Post Malone. Critics, including The Independent’s Helen Brown, have been quick to praise the album, calling it a “terrific reminder of her storytelling powers.”
Awards and Recognition
Swift is no stranger to awards, and the 2024 VMAs are shaping up to be yet another moment in the spotlight for her. With a whopping 12 nominations, she leads the pack, a testament to her enduring relevance and creative growth. While she won’t be performing at the event, fans can look forward to other live performances from major names like Eminem, Megan Thee Stallion, and Shawn Mendes.
But the accolades don’t stop there. Swift's ability to evolve while staying true to her roots is one of the reasons she continues to win over both critics and fans. From her early country roots to her more recent foray into alternative and indie sounds, her musical journey has been nothing short of remarkable. Each album feels like a chapter in a larger story that keeps unfolding, leaving fans eager for what comes next.
The Underrated Genius of Taylor Swift
For an artist who’s been in the public eye for over a decade, Swift continues to surprise and impress. Gradvall’s assertion that she remains underrated is a powerful reminder that even someone as celebrated as Swift can still have layers of talent that haven’t been fully acknowledged. Sure, there’s the mainstream success, the magazine covers, and the sold-out stadium tours, but it’s the depth of her songwriting and the genuine connection she shares with her fans that truly sets her apart.
In a world where the spotlight is often fleeting, Taylor Swift has managed to not just survive but thrive. Her songs will likely be sung by generations to come, and her performances will go down in history as some of the most memorable of this era. Whether or not you’re a die-hard fan, it’s hard to deny the impact she’s had—and will continue to have—on the music industry.
So, is Taylor Swift underrated? If you ask Jan Gradvall, the answer is a resounding yes, and his case is backed up by the millions of fans and countless industry professionals who continue to be mesmerized by her talent. Swift’s legacy isn’t just set in stone—it’s still being written, and the chapters to come are bound to be just as thrilling as the ones we’ve already read.
Login