With nearly all of the ballots counted in the 2024 election, it’s time to take a closer look at how the federaland battleground polls performed this cycle. While the polling wasn’t flawless, the results were far more accurate than some may have expected, especially considering the challenges and setbacks the polling industry has faced recently.
A Deep Dive into the Polls: How Close Were They?
Let’s begin with the presidential race numbers. The final national poll from NBC News showed the contest between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris locked in a tight tie, with both candidates sitting at 49%. The RealClearPolitics average of the two-way contest at a national level had Harris just a hair ahead, with 48.7% compared to Trump’s 48.6%. Similarly, The New York Times’ poll showed a similar trend, with Harris at 49% and Trump trailing by just a fraction at 48%.
So, what did the actual result look like? As of now, with some final ballots still being counted, the popular vote stands at Trump 49.9%, Harris 48.3%. While the polls may have slightly overestimated Harris’ support and slightly underestimated Trump’s, the gap was incredibly narrow. In fact, the polling performance for 2024 ranks among the best in recent presidential elections, especially when compared to the dramatic polling misses of the 2020 cycle.
Battleground Polls: Close, But Not Perfect
Moving on to battleground states, the polling here wasn’t off by much either, though the results were slightly more divergent than those seen in the national polls. In battleground states, the margins of error tended to be a little wider, but the general picture painted by the polls was still mostly accurate in terms of who the key swing states leaned toward. These polls also reflected how tight the race was nationally.
If there’s any misconception that the polls in 2024 were “wrong,” it’s largely due to the unrealistic expectations that come with interpreting political horse race numbers. Many people assume that a poll showing candidates at 49% to 48% can offer a precise prediction of who will win the election and by what margin. However, polling isn’t an exact science, and that level of precision is rarely achievable.
Understanding Polling Errors: The Bigger Picture
Polling has always been a bit of a moving target. A range of factors—such as margins of error, fluctuating voter response rates, and different assumptions about who will actually turn out to vote—can influence the results. These factors make it clear that expecting perfect precision from political polls is a fool’s errand. A poll showing a close race (such as 49%-48%) simply tells us that the election is up in the air, not that a certain candidate will win by a landslide.
This is something to keep in mind when interpreting polling data. In fact, the 2024 election was exactly what the polls predicted it would be: a tight contest. The polls painted an accurate picture of just how competitive the race would be, both nationally and in crucial swing states.
The Polls Got the Political Landscape Right
But the polls didn’t just get the race itself right—they also captured the broader political atmosphere that shaped the election. One of the most striking elements the polls predicted was the public dissatisfaction with the direction of the country. Many voters felt the nation was heading in the wrong direction, which, combined with an incumbent president whose approval ratings were struggling, helped to set the stage for the intense competition we saw.
The NBC News Exit Poll showed that a staggering 73% of voters expressed anger or dissatisfaction with the country’s direction. Only 40% approved of President Biden’s job performance, which placed him in a historically precarious position heading into the election. These sentiments were critical in shaping the political narrative of 2024, and the polls were spot on in capturing this sentiment.
A Critical Look at Polling Challenges
Despite these successes, the polling industry continues to face serious challenges that make it difficult to predict elections with total accuracy. One of the most significant hurdles is the ever-declining response rates from voters, which affects the quality of the data collected. In an era of skepticism toward institutions and political polarization, it’s harder than ever to reach a representative sample of voters. This, in turn, complicates efforts to ensure the results are as accurate as possible.
Moreover, the electorate itself is constantly evolving. The rise of new voting groups, changing attitudes, and unpredictable factors like last-minute political shifts or scandals can significantly influence the outcome of an election, making it even harder for polls to stay on track.
Beyond the Numbers: What Polls Really Tell Us
Ultimately, what polls are best at is providing a snapshot of the political climate, signaling how competitive an election might be. The notion that polls can perfectly predict an election’s outcome by pinning down exact vote percentages is unrealistic. Instead, what polls excel at is showing trends, uncovering public sentiment, and painting a general picture of how tight or loose the race is. That’s exactly what we saw in 2024: a nail-biting, competitive election.
In this context, the 2024 polling data did its job. It clearly communicated how tight the race was, even though it couldn’t predict every nuance of the final outcome. The polls provided a solid foundation for understanding the political environment, even if they weren’t flawless in predicting the precise winner.
Final Thoughts: A Sign of Progress
Looking at the results from 2024, one thing is clear: polling is making progress. While it may never be able to offer pinpoint accuracy, it’s far more reliable than it was just a few years ago. The 2024 polls—while not perfect—were among the most accurate in recent history, and they certainly provided a better reflection of the race than the massive polling errors seen in 2020.
So, when evaluating the performance of polls, it’s important to remember what they are: tools for gauging the pulse of the nation, not crystal balls that can predict the future with exact precision. The polls in 2024 showed us a close, competitive election, and that’s exactly what we got. Given the many challenges faced by the polling industry, this was a significant achievement.
As we move forward, the key takeaway is that political polling has room for improvement, but it remains a vital part of understanding the landscape of U.S. elections. And while there’s no magic formula for perfect predictions, the more we understand the complexities and limitations of polling, the better we can interpret the results and use them to inform our view of the political world.
Login