Kamala Harris has been under increasing scrutiny from top Democrats as concerns grow over her appeal to working-class voters, particularly in the key "blue-wall" states like Michigan. This pressure stems from the rising influence of Donald Trump, who has been aggressively targeting union members and white voters without a college education. Trump's focus on issues like high living costs, the manufacturing industry, and economic competition with China has resonated with these voters, making them crucial in the 2024 race. Democrats are realizing that if Harris wants to secure the electoral college votes necessary to win the presidency, she’ll need to strengthen her connection with these critical demographics.
Michigan at the Heart of Democratic Concerns
In Michigan, the anxiety over Harris’s performance is particularly palpable. The state has long been a battleground for working-class voters, and its union ties make it a pivotal target for any presidential hopeful. Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer, a rising star in the Democratic Party, has reportedly been urging Harris's campaign to sharpen its economic message to resonate better with the state's blue-collar voters. Whitmer and others want Harris to spend more time in Michigan, connecting with voters by emphasizing the administration’s efforts to boost the automotive industry, open new manufacturing plants, and secure jobs for the future. These issues are central to Michigan’s economy, especially as auto workers face uncertainty due to the rapid shift toward electric vehicles (EVs).
Democrats in the state are calling for Harris to adopt a more populist tone, a sentiment echoed by progressive figures like Bernie Sanders and United Auto Workers (UAW) President Shawn Fain. During a recent rally in Grand Rapids, Sanders pushed progressive ideals like raising the minimum wage, expanding Social Security, and taxing the wealthy to curb corporate greed. Sanders passionately declared, "We have to build a political movement led by trade unions to challenge the power of the billionaire class." His remarks were aimed at energizing the Democratic base, reinforcing the need to elect Harris and keep Donald Trump out of office. The stakes are high, and Michigan’s working-class voters could be the deciding factor.
Harris Faces Tight Polling in Crucial States
Polling in Michigan and other blue-wall states shows a razor-thin margin between Harris and Trump. Recent surveys indicate that the two are locked in a dead heat across Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. These three states were crucial to Joe Biden’s victory in 2020, and their importance in 2024 cannot be overstated. Internal polling from Democratic Senator Tammy Baldwin’s campaign in Wisconsin revealed that Harris is trailing Trump by three points, while Baldwin herself is ahead by two. This underscores how Harris is struggling to garner support from non-college-educated men, a demographic that Republicans have historically dominated.
Harris’s challenges with organized labor are also concerning. While she’s secured endorsements from major unions like the UAW and the Service Employees International Union (SEIU), others—such as the International Brotherhood of Teamsters and the International Association of Fire Fighters—have withheld their support. This lack of endorsement, particularly from the firefighters' union, was a significant blow. The campaign had even planned a labor-themed event in Redford Township, Michigan, assuming they would receive the endorsement, but when it didn’t come through, they had to shift the focus of the event.
Addressing Concerns and Misinformation
Republicans have not hesitated to pounce on Harris’s vulnerabilities, particularly her positions on key issues like fracking and electric vehicles. During her 2019 presidential campaign, Harris was an outspoken advocate for tougher emissions standards and even floated the idea of banning fracking, a position that resonated with environmentalists but alienated many working-class voters, especially in states like Pennsylvania where fracking is a significant industry. Since then, she has walked back some of these stances, but Republicans have used them to paint her as out of touch with the economic realities facing many Americans.
Corey Lewandowski, a longtime Trump advisor, didn’t hold back, stating that “people see Harris as the most radical, dangerous nominee of a major party in history.” He went on to say that Michigan’s auto industry workers are fully aware of Harris’s supposed threats to their livelihood. Harris has worked to counteract this narrative. In Flint, Michigan, she addressed claims from the Trump campaign that she wants to eliminate gas-powered cars. “Contrary to what my opponent is suggesting, I will never tell you what kind of car you have to drive,” Harris assured the crowd, making it clear that her policies won’t harm Michigan’s iconic automotive industry.
A Path Forward for Harris
Despite the challenges, Harris’s team remains optimistic. They argue that the vice president has consistently engaged with voters in the blue-wall states, noting her frequent visits to Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. The campaign has also invested in extensive advertising targeted specifically at working-class voters. In September, Harris delivered an economic speech in Pittsburgh focused on revitalizing American manufacturing—a key issue for voters in these battleground states.
The Harris campaign believes that her proposals to combat price-gouging and lower prescription drug prices will resonate with voters. Additionally, allies like Bernie Sanders and UAW President Shawn Fain have praised the administration’s industrial policy and the new electric vehicle plants funded through the Inflation Reduction Act. Fain, when asked if Harris should push back harder against Trump’s rhetoric on electric vehicles, responded that the administration should be “more vocal” about its successes in bringing new jobs to Michigan.
Governor Whitmer echoed these sentiments during a rally in Flint, driving home the message that jobs are the top priority for voters in Michigan. “Jobs, jobs, and jobs,” Whitmer chanted with the crowd, underscoring the administration’s commitment to securing employment for working-class families. Magic Johnson, a beloved Michigan native and basketball legend, also appeared at the event, lending his star power to the campaign’s efforts to win over undecided voters.
A Close Race with High Stakes
As the 2024 election draws near, the stakes for Harris in the blue-wall states couldn’t be higher. Former President Barack Obama is set to join her on the campaign trail, starting with an event in Pittsburgh. His presence is a reminder of the significance of these states, which helped propel him to victory in both 2008 and 2012. Harris’s team knows that winning the support of moderate and independent voters in these regions will be crucial.
Former Representative Conor Lamb, who once represented a swing district in western Pennsylvania, pointed out that while Harris has made progress, she still has work to do to win over the final group of persuadable voters. “We need more unfiltered messaging from the vice president—town halls, interviews, opportunities to connect directly with voters,” Lamb suggested. For Harris, this kind of direct engagement could be the key to swinging the election in her favor.
In the final weeks leading up to the election, Harris’s allies remain confident that she can win over the working-class voters who will ultimately decide the fate of the blue wall. "People don't know her well enough yet," said former Michigan Governor James Blanchard, adding that Harris is the “perfect candidate” for the state. With the race so tight, every speech, every appearance, and every rally counts, and the campaign is determined to do everything it can to secure a victory in Michigan and the other key battlegrounds.
Login