The Economic Showdown: Trump vs. Biden
As we navigate the complex waters of American politics and economics, one fact stands out: the economy remains a central talking point for both political leaders and voters alike. Former President Donald Trump is confidently leveraging his economic record from his four years in office, while Vice President Kamala Harris, though not officially in charge of the White House, is intrinsically tied to President Joe Biden’s economic policies. This dynamic creates an interesting backdrop for discussions about their respective economic legacies.
Polling Perspectives: Trump’s Advantage
Poll after poll has consistently shown that Americans tend to rate Trump more favorably on economic performance compared to Biden. This situation has caused some frustration among Biden’s advisors, who feel that the president isn’t getting the recognition he deserves for his economic achievements. In recent months, however, it appears that Harris is closing the gap on economic perceptions, even though she still lags behind Trump. So, what exactly does the data reveal about how Trump and Biden stack up economically?
A Closer Look at Economic Performance
When attempting to compare the economic performance during the Biden administration to that of Trump, things can get a bit murky. The pandemic caused significant disruptions during the final year of Trump’s term and continued into Biden’s presidency. Both leaders might be eager to point fingers at the circumstances beyond their control, but the reality remains that they were both at the helm during these tumultuous times. Let’s break down their records.
GDP Growth: A Tale of Two Terms
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) serves as the broadest measure of economic performance. Under Trump, the first three years saw robust growth, with inflation-adjusted GDP growing at an annual rate of 2.8% from Q4 2016 to Q4 2019. However, the onset of the pandemic severely affected GDP growth, ultimately lowering the average annual growth rate for Trump’s entire term to 1.8%.
In contrast, Biden’s economic trajectory has been more favorable. The rebound following the pandemic has propelled GDP growth to a remarkable 3.2% annual rate from the end of 2020 through Q2 of the current year. To put it into perspective, GDP under Trump grew 7.6% over his four years, while Biden has seen an impressive 11.8% growth thus far in his presidency.
Economists anticipate that the upcoming third-quarter GDP report from the Commerce Department, due out at the end of October, will continue this trend of strong growth. If predictions hold true, Biden’s term may well mark the most significant GDP growth since Bill Clinton’s last four years in office.
Inflation: A Troubling Comparison
While GDP figures paint a promising picture for Biden, inflation tells a different story—one that is far less favorable. During Trump’s first three years, inflation remained relatively tame, with the Consumer Price Index rising a modest 7.8% from January 2017 to January 2021. However, as Biden took office, inflation began to surge, and despite recent cooling trends, consumers are still grappling with significant price hikes. By September 2023, consumer prices had soared nearly 20% above their January 2021 levels.
This inflation spike is reminiscent of the economic turmoil during Ronald Reagan’s first term when prices surged by 21%. However, Reagan had the advantage of having a predecessor—Jimmy Carter—who faced even higher inflation rates, which set a lower bar for recovery.
The inflationary pressures during Biden’s presidency can be attributed to various factors, including pandemic-induced supply chain disruptions and skyrocketing oil prices due to geopolitical tensions like Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Interestingly, inflation isn’t just an American issue; similar price increases are being felt across Europe. However, Americans are primarily concerned about their own financial realities, and high inflation continues to negatively impact Biden’s approval ratings regarding economic management.
Employment Landscape: Jobs, Jobs, Jobs
Let’s shift gears and examine the job market under both administrations. During Trump’s initial three years, the economy saw the addition of 6.7 million jobs, but that number plummeted in March and April 2020, when the nation lost a staggering 21.9 million jobs due to pandemic lockdowns. By the end of 2020, the labor market had still not fully recovered, leaving 2.7 million fewer jobs than at the end of 2016.
In contrast, Biden has presided over a significant job recovery. As of September 2023, the U.S. has added an impressive 16.2 million jobs since Biden took office. Even with potential revisions in the numbers, this growth represents the strongest annual pace of job creation over a presidential term, as measured by percentage, since Jimmy Carter’s presidency ended in January 1981.
Many economists have been pleasantly surprised by the strength of job growth during Biden’s tenure, surpassing initial expectations. Before the pandemic struck, the Congressional Budget Office projected that the U.S. would average around 155.1 million jobs by the third quarter of 2024. However, as of now, the actual number exceeds that projection by over three million jobs.
Unemployment Rates: A Parallel Journey
The unemployment rate tells a similar story to that of job growth. Under Trump, the unemployment rate dropped from 4.7% at the start of his presidency to a low of 3.5% before the pandemic struck. The subsequent lockdowns sent unemployment soaring, reaching a record high before stabilizing at 6.4% in January 2021.
Under Biden, the unemployment rate has seen a decline, dipping into the 5% and 4% ranges. Last year, it even matched a historic low of 3.4%. However, the rate has since climbed back up to around 4.1%, leaving many to wonder about the sustainability of this trend.
Household Income: The Ups and Downs
Examining household income provides another critical angle in this economic discussion. Census Bureau data indicates that real household incomes surged during Trump’s first three years but took a hit in his final year, partially due to pandemic-related distortions. Specifically, a 2020 survey captured an inflated median income figure—7.2% higher than 2019—because it disproportionately included higher-income individuals during the pandemic’s worst months. In reality, median incomes were 8.2% higher in 2020 than in 2016.
Under Biden, the impact of inflation has dampened household income growth, particularly in 2022. As of last year, real median income had increased by a mere 1.3% from 2020 levels. Analysts from Motio Research have noted a slight rise since then, but it’s likely that income growth under Biden will still fall short of the increases seen during Trump’s administration.
Wealth Creation: The Full Picture
When it comes to wealth creation, Trump’s presidency is marked by significant gains for many Americans. By the end of 2019, the average real net worth for households in the middle-income bracket was up by 13.5% compared to the end of 2016. This figure ballooned to around 30% by the end of 2020, fueled by a booming stock market, rising home prices, and extensive government relief efforts during the pandemic.
While Biden has also seen stocks and home prices rise, inflation has significantly dampened these gains. Many households have depleted the savings they amassed through government stimulus payments during both Trump’s and Biden’s terms. By Q2 of this year, real net worth for middle-income households was only up by 4.6% compared to the end of 2020.
Wealth accumulation has proven to be uneven during Biden’s presidency. Homeowners have benefitted from rising property values, yet many non-homeowners are feeling the pinch as high mortgage rates and inflated home prices make home ownership increasingly unattainable.
Conclusion: The Ongoing Economic Debate
As the political landscape evolves and elections loom on the horizon, the economic debate between Trump and Biden remains heated. Both leaders have faced unique challenges during their tenures, and their records reflect a complex interplay of successes and failures.
While Trump can tout impressive GDP growth and job creation during his time in office, Biden is grappling with the repercussions of inflation and the lingering effects of the pandemic. The coming months will undoubtedly provide more data to further inform this debate, but one thing is clear: the American economy is an ever-changing landscape that will continue to be a focal point for politicians and voters alike.
The ultimate question remains: Who will take credit for the economic trends, and how will they leverage these narratives as we head toward future elections? Only time will tell, but the ongoing economic discourse is bound to keep Americans engaged and interested in the political arena.
Login