“History Will Redeem Us”: A Columbia Grad’s Fiery Letter from Detention Exposes Suppression of Student Dissent
From a detention center in Louisiana, Columbia University graduate Mahmoud Khalil is sounding the alarm — and not just for himself.
His powerful message, dictated to his attorney and published in The Columbia Spectator, paints a chilling picture of what he calls a systematic attack on student activism, particularly around Palestine. Khalil, a Syrian-born permanent U.S. resident, wasn’t just voicing concern from the sidelines. He was on the front lines, helping lead antiwar protests on Columbia’s campus last year. And now, he’s sitting in federal custody — detained without charge.
But let’s back up.
A Familiar Pattern of Repression
For Khalil, this isn’t the first time he’s felt the weight of institutional oppression.
“The situation is oddly reminiscent of when I fled the brutality of Bashar al-Assad’s regime in Syria and sought refuge in Lebanon,” he said.
Let that sink in. A man who fled a brutal dictatorship now finds himself detained in the United States — not for any criminal act, but for his participation in peaceful protest.
And he isn’t alone.
Several other international students across the country, all vocal supporters of Palestinian rights, are facing threats of deportation, or have already been detained. Among them are Yunseo Chung, Ranjani Srinivasan, Leqaa Kordia, Dr. Badar Khan Suri, and Rümeysa Öztürk. Some were enrolled at other universities, yet their stories echo Khalil’s: young people targeted for their activism, for their voices.
What’s Really Going on at Columbia?
Khalil accuses Columbia University of playing a key role in this broader crackdown. He calls it the “repression playbook” — a strategy, he argues, that disguises itself as a stand against antisemitism, but in practice works to silence pro-Palestinian advocacy.
Here’s what he claims is happening on campus:
-
Congress got access to student disciplinary records
-
A new task force was created that allegedly equates criticism of Israel with hate speech
-
An office meant to investigate discrimination became, in his words, “a mechanism to persecute pro-Palestinian students with no due process”
The timing, too, raises eyebrows. The university’s shift toward heightened surveillance and disciplinary measures seemed to come after threats from the Trump administration to withdraw funding from institutions that didn’t fall in line with its restrictive views on campus speech.
Leadership in Crisis
Following the resignation of Columbia’s interim president Katrina Armstrong, Khalil says the Board of Trustees made a critical error. Instead of restoring academic integrity, they appointed one of their own — a move he says set the institution ablaze.
“They opted to set fire to the institution they’re entrusted with,” Khalil wrote.
To faculty members who pride themselves on being progressive but stop short of meaningful action, he posed a biting question:
“Are your positions worth more than the lives of your students and the integrity of your work?”
A Student Movement Rooted in Solidarity
Despite the repression, Khalil remains inspired by the movement he helped grow. It wasn’t just about protests and slogans. It was a grassroots community, centered around care, education, and action.
-
Students organized mutual aid for families in Gaza through bake sales and online fundraisers
-
They created safe study spaces, book clubs, and solidarity circles
-
They collaborated across causes — building bridges with other justice movements on campus
“This movement has always been grassroots,” Khalil emphasized. “It was led by students – many younger than me – who risked their careers, their degrees and their futures to demand divestment.”
These students weren’t acting out of self-interest. They saw injustice and refused to stay silent. And now, they’re being punished for that moral clarity.
“Your Neutrality Won’t Save You”
In his most sobering remarks, Khalil offers a warning — not just to those in power, but to students who have chosen to stay neutral.
“As pressure from the federal government intensifies, know that your neutrality on Palestine will not protect you,” he wrote. “When the time comes for the federal government to target other causes, it will be your names that Columbia will offer on a silver platter.”
In other words: If you think silence will shield you, think again.
A Fight That’s Far from Over
Khalil knows that the path forward won’t be easy. His own freedom remains uncertain as his legal case continues in New Jersey. Yet from inside a detention cell, he remains hopeful — and defiant.
“The student movement will continue to carry the mantle of a free Palestine,” he vowed. “History will redeem us, while those who were content to wait on the sidelines will be forever remembered for their silence.”
Why This Matters Beyond Columbia
This isn’t just a Columbia issue. This is about how universities across the United States are being used — or coerced — into becoming tools of state repression. It's about how activism is being criminalized, and how dissent is being squashed under the banner of "safety" or "neutrality."
But most of all, it’s about the courage of students who refuse to back down.
They’re not just marching for Palestine — they’re standing up for free speech, academic freedom, and human dignity.
So if you’re reading this and you’re on a college campus, or in a classroom, or working at an institution that values open dialogue — ask yourself:
-
Are you listening to your peers?
-
Are you defending their right to protest, even if you don’t agree with the cause?
-
Will you speak up before your voice is the one they try to silence next?
Final Thoughts from Khalil
He didn’t ask for sympathy — he asked for solidarity.
Mahmoud Khalil’s words may have come from behind locked doors, but they carry across campus greens, lecture halls, and student unions nationwide. His story is a call to action — one that challenges students, educators, and institutions alike to choose a side in a growing struggle between repression and resistance.
Because in the end, as Khalil so passionately put it:
“History will redeem us.”
And the question that lingers: Which side of history will you be on?
Login