It’s official — New York Republican Rep. Mike Lawler is staying put in the House of Representatives, putting to rest weeks of speculation about whether he might leap into the governor's race against Kathy Hochul. Instead, Lawler is betting on continuity, and in doing so, he’s giving Donald Trump and House Republicans a key win in their high-stakes push to keep the razor-thin GOP majority intact.
“After months of deliberating over this and really working through it, I’ve decided the right thing to do for me and my family and my district is to run for reelection,” Lawler told Fox News on Wednesday.
It might sound like a personal choice — and of course it is — but Lawler’s decision resonates far beyond his Hudson Valley district. With control of the House expected to be decided by just a handful of seats in 2024, every incumbent matters. And Lawler’s seat? It’s one of the biggest political battlegrounds in the country.
Let’s rewind a bit. In 2022, Lawler stunned the political world by flipping the 17th District, unseating none other than Sean Patrick Maloney, who at the time was heading up the House Democrats’ campaign arm. It was the GOP’s biggest upset of the cycle — a total shake-up in what had traditionally been considered blue turf. Lawler then cemented his hold in 2024 by defeating Mondaire Jones, but Democrats aren’t about to back off. With whispers that Maloney himself might mount a comeback in 2026, the fight for the 17th could become one of the fiercest in the country.
Now, here’s where Trump enters the picture. Behind the scenes, Trump had made it known that he wanted Lawler to remain in Congress rather than gamble with a statewide bid that could leave his House seat vulnerable.
“Keeping the House majority is critical if we’re going to continue to move this economy in the right direction,” Lawler said in the same Fox News interview. “I’m proud to have delivered on my key promise, which was to lift the cap on SALT in the one big, beautiful bill.”
That reference to SALT (State and Local Tax deduction cap) is a not-so-subtle reminder to his base — especially voters in high-tax New York suburbs — that he’s delivered real, tangible wins. According to Lawler, the SALT adjustment is “the single largest tax cut in the whole bill,” a feather in his cap as he heads into another reelection campaign.
But what about that buzz around him possibly challenging Gov. Kathy Hochul? It wasn’t just idle chatter. Lawler hasn’t held back in criticizing her.
“She’s the worst governor in America,” he said bluntly, suggesting that she needs to be ousted in 2026.
Still, for now, he’s leaving that mission to someone else — maybe even Rep. Elise Stefanik, another New York Republican whose name keeps popping up in conversations about the 2026 gubernatorial race. Stefanik, who recently launched a statewide PAC and quietly ran internal polling against Hochul, has yet to make her move official.
“Mike Lawler is a great, effective, and hardworking Representative for New York’s 17th Congressional District,” Stefanik said in a statement. “I will make a final decision and announcement after this year’s November election, which we are all focused on.”
Stefanik, it’s worth noting, was even floated earlier this year for a possible U.S. ambassador to the United Nations gig — a move Trump nixed, fearing it could cost the GOP its thin House edge.
That razor-thin margin is exactly why Trump and his team are watching these decisions so closely. They’re playing the long game, and Lawler’s commitment to run again is a chess move in the larger strategy of keeping the House red.
Behind the scenes, Trump is also eyeing more aggressive redistricting tactics in places like Texas, where his team believes they can squeeze out five more GOP-friendly seats. Every seat counts, and Lawler’s reelection helps plug a potential leak.
Quick Hits: Why Lawler’s Run Matters
-
Strategic for Trump: Lawler staying in the House preserves a crucial seat in the GOP’s fight to maintain control.
-
Red District in Blue Territory: His district was one of only three in the country to back Kamala Harris in 2024 while electing a Republican to the House.
-
Dem Threat Looms: With big Democratic names like Maloney potentially eyeing a comeback, Lawler won’t have a cakewalk in 2026.
-
Policy Wins: The SALT cap repeal gives Lawler a legislative win he can point to with suburban voters.
And let’s not forget Rep. Don Bacon of Nebraska, who’s choosing to retire this cycle. His seat is another one Republicans could lose — making Lawler’s decision to run again even more crucial. The GOP simply can’t afford to lose ground in competitive districts like New York’s 17th.
Trump, for his part, is staying laser-focused. Whether it’s twisting arms behind closed doors or strategically pulling nominations, he’s working overtime to make sure the House remains under Republican control.
So what’s next for Lawler?
Expect a fiery, well-funded reelection battle — one that will likely draw national media, boatloads of campaign cash, and maybe even a few surprise endorsements. Whether Democrats throw Maloney back into the ring or go with fresh blood, it’s clear this seat isn’t just a local race anymore — it’s a microcosm of the national power struggle playing out in real time.
In short, Lawler’s decision might look like a quiet political move from a New York Congressman — but it’s a thunderclap in the grander scheme of American politics. It gives Trump’s team breathing room, re-energizes GOP strategy, and guarantees that the Hudson Valley will once again be a political battlefield in 2024.
Buckle up — it’s going to be one heck of a race.
Login