President Donald Trump made a bold move on Thursday, flanked by students and educators, as he signed an executive order aimed at fundamentally dismantling the federal Department of Education. This action fulfills a long-standing campaign promise to conservatives who have advocated for a decentralized education system. By shifting control over education policy almost entirely to states and local school boards, the order has sparked both applause and alarm.
A Step Toward Eliminating the Department of Education
During the signing ceremony in the East Room of the White House, Trump stood before a backdrop of colorful state flags, emphasizing his commitment to "returning education, very simply, back to the states where it belongs." While completely shutting down the agency requires congressional approval—a challenge given the current political landscape—Trump's executive order sets the stage for a significant reduction in federal oversight.
To illustrate his point, young students attending the event participated in a symbolic moment, sitting at classroom desks and signing their own mock executive orders alongside the president. This act served as a powerful visual representation of his administration’s push for state-controlled education.
The Battle Over Education Control
Education policy has long been a contentious issue in American politics. Conservatives generally favor local control and school-choice initiatives that support private and religious institutions, while progressives advocate for strong federal funding and diversity programs in public education. Trump's move takes this battle to a new level, framing it as part of a broader effort against what many conservatives see as liberal indoctrination in schools.
The debate has only intensified in recent years. During the COVID-19 pandemic, parents voiced strong opposition at school board meetings across the country, decrying everything from mask mandates to curriculum changes. This dissatisfaction became a rallying cry for Trump, other Republican candidates, and conservative advocacy groups like Moms for Liberty.
Federal Cuts and Job Losses
The Department of Education has already begun shrinking under Trump’s directive. Just last week, it announced plans to lay off nearly half of its staff, aligning with the administration’s broader efforts to cut down what it views as bloated and inefficient government agencies. Trump's White House argues that the department has failed to deliver on its mission, pointing to stagnant test scores, low literacy rates, and weak math performance as evidence that its multi-trillion-dollar budget has not translated into real results.
Higher Education Under Fire
Trump’s efforts extend beyond K-12 education, targeting colleges and universities as well. His administration has sought to reduce funding and eliminate diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) policies from higher education institutions, mirroring similar efforts in other federal agencies. For example, Columbia University faced a deadline on Thursday to comply with demands for stricter protest regulations as a condition for reopening discussions on reinstating $400 million in frozen federal funding.
The Role of the Department of Education
Despite efforts to dismantle it, the Department of Education plays a crucial role in overseeing America’s educational infrastructure. It supports approximately 100,000 public schools and 34,000 private schools nationwide. Although over 85% of public school funding comes from state and local governments, the department provides essential federal grants that assist underfunded schools, finance arts programs, and replace outdated facilities. Additionally, it manages $1.6 trillion in student loans, which millions of Americans rely on to afford higher education.
For now, Trump’s executive order trims the department’s responsibilities down to administering student loans, Pell Grants for low-income students, and resources for children with special needs. “We’re going to shut it down and shut it down as quickly as possible,” Trump declared, reiterating his stance that the department serves no useful purpose.
Opposition and Legal Challenges
Democratic leaders were quick to push back. U.S. Senator Patty Murray called Trump’s move an attempt to “smash [the department] to pieces” despite lacking congressional approval. Teachers' unions also signaled their readiness for a legal battle. Randi Weingarten, head of the American Federation of Teachers, issued a sharp warning: "See you in court."
Although Republicans control both chambers of Congress, eliminating the Department of Education entirely would require a 60-vote majority in the Senate—an unlikely scenario given Democratic opposition. Trump acknowledged that bipartisan cooperation would be necessary but remained defiant, insisting he would press forward with his goal.
Public Opinion and Political Reality
A recent Reuters/Ipsos poll suggests that a majority of Americans oppose closing the Department of Education. The survey, conducted nationwide with 4,145 U.S. adults, found that 65% of respondents were against shutting it down, compared to only 30% in favor. The poll’s margin of error was about two percentage points.
Interestingly, federal education aid disproportionately benefits Republican-leaning states. According to a Reuters analysis of Census Bureau data, federal funding made up 15% of K-12 revenue in states that voted for Trump in the 2024 election, compared to 11% in states that backed Democratic candidate Kamala Harris. Two of the largest federal aid programs—support for low-income schools and funding for students with special needs—could be significantly impacted if the department were to be dismantled.
The Road Ahead
While Trump’s executive order does not immediately shut down the Department of Education, it marks a significant step toward reshaping America’s educational landscape. The battle over federal versus state control of education is far from over, and with legal challenges and public opposition mounting, the future of the department remains uncertain.
Trump remains determined to see his vision through. Whether or not he succeeds in completely eliminating the department, his efforts have already ignited a national debate about the role of the federal government in education—a debate that will likely continue well beyond his presidency.
Login