Donald Trump is finding himself in some of the most challenging polling numbers of his entire career, and trust me, that's no small feat given how bumpy his political ride has been from the start. For the majority of his first term, Trump leaned heavily on the idea that he was the guy who could fix the economy and secure the border. These two pillars helped him weather the storm of controversy that seemed to follow him everywhere. But now, in his second term, things are looking different. Polls coming in as he hits the first 100 days of his return show major cracks in his foundation—his support on key issues like the economy and immigration is showing signs of serious wear and tear, especially as he shifts toward more extreme policies.
The Economy: Trump's Achilles Heel?
Let’s talk about the economy first. Recent polls have found Trump sitting at some of his worst approval ratings for his economic policies ever. The Reuters poll, for example, shows him with a dismal 37% approval for his handling of the economy—his lowest ever. And that’s a problem. For most of his first term, Trump had a solid reputation as a steward of the economy, but these numbers indicate that his economic agenda just isn’t resonating with the people anymore. Whether it’s his trade war, tariffs, or policies that seem to be shaking up the markets, Trump’s economic performance is leaving many wondering what happened to the promises he made.
His tough stance on immigration is also taking a hit. While his polling numbers aren’t as bleak as they are on the economy, they’ve definitely taken a dive. His aggressive deportation campaign, which has even impacted U.S. citizens and people legally residing in the country, has erased whatever edge he once had on the issue. As a result, his standing on immigration is starting to erode, too. The days of having clear support on these issues seem to be slipping through his fingers.
Trump’s Plummeting Approval Ratings: A Major Concern
Trump’s unfavorable numbers have been steadily rising since he took office for a second time, with a recent New York Times poll showing 52% disapproval. Just to put that into context, both Joe Biden and Barack Obama were performing better than Trump at this point in their presidencies. And it doesn’t help that his approval numbers are hovering just above the dismal levels he saw in his first term. Take a moment to think about that: it’s been eight years since he was in office, and he’s still struggling to turn around that first-term reputation.
Now, let’s be clear: Trump didn’t start his second term in a position of strength. He inherited the second-worst approval ratings in modern presidential history—only Dwight D. Eisenhower, who was new to politics, had worse numbers. And here we are again, with polling showing no signs of improvement. It’s worth noting that, despite all of this, Trump’s numbers in some recent polls are still better than they were for him in his first term, but even that small silver lining doesn’t mask the larger trends at play.
A Shifting Landscape: How Voters Are Reacting
Looking at the latest polling from sources like The Economist and YouGov, Trump is now dealing with a 13-point negative approval rating—a significant drop from just a week ago. This sharp decline is even more pronounced when you compare it to Joe Biden’s performance at the same point in his presidency, where he was up 11 points. The contrast is stark, and it paints a picture of a president losing support in real-time.
Breaking the numbers down by demographics shows just how broad the discontent is. According to new data from Pew Research, Trump is in negative territory across nearly every demographic group. Men, women, people of color, and those with varying levels of education—all of them view his presidency more negatively than positively. He’s facing a wave of disapproval that crosses party lines, and it seems no issue is safe. Whether it’s immigration, trade, public health, or foreign policy, Trump’s approval has cratered. There’s no area where he can point to a net-positive approval rating.
The Economy, Again: Why It’s Dragging Trump Down
But let’s focus again on the economy, because this seems to be the issue that’s really pulling Trump down. His trade war, particularly the tariffs he imposed on both friend and foe alike, has rattled global markets. The resulting uncertainty has put a serious dent in Trump’s economic record. Meanwhile, his harsh immigration policies—especially the mass deportations—have created a situation where employers are struggling to find the low-cost labor they need. On top of that, his frequent reshuffling of government agencies and constant changes to policies have made him seem unpredictable, which isn’t exactly the hallmark of good leadership.
Polling data from Gallup also reveals just how bad economic confidence has become, with the country expressing the lowest level of economic optimism since 2001. This could be a huge blow for Trump, considering how central the economy has been to his platform.
The Big Shift: Independents Are Turning Away
One of the biggest reasons Trump is in trouble now is the shift among independent voters. These are the voters who often hold the key to winning elections, and they’ve been moving away from Trump in significant numbers. A Quinnipiac poll from January showed that 46% of independents disapproved of Trump; that number has now surged to 58%. That’s a massive 12-point swing, and it’s one that could have serious consequences in 2024. Independents have become a crack in the foundation of Trump’s support, and it’s a crack that’s growing wider every day.
This change is particularly important because it’s not just about how Trump is faring with Democrats or Republicans—it’s about those voters in the middle who can go either way. If these independents continue to disapprove of Trump, it could spell trouble for his re-election campaign.
Trouble Among Republicans: A Warning Sign?
And it’s not just the independents that are showing signs of strain. Even within Trump’s own party, there are hints of dissatisfaction. A recent Fox News poll asked GOP voters how they felt about Trump’s prospects for a second term. While 75% of Republicans said they were “encouraged” about the next four years, that’s down from 84% at the same point during his first term. It’s a slight dip, but it’s a dip nonetheless. If this trend continues, it could suggest that the enthusiasm Trump once enjoyed among his base might be waning.
The Democrats: A Ray of Hope?
While Trump’s numbers continue to slip, this shift in public opinion could provide a boost to Democrats, who have been struggling to find a strategy to counteract Trump’s moves. The rising discontent among key voter groups, especially independents, presents an opening for the opposition. This is a moment for Democrats to capitalize on the growing dissatisfaction with Trump’s leadership, especially as his support continues to erode.
The Road Ahead: A Troubling Outlook for Republicans
As we look ahead to the next election, the growing signs of trouble for Trump should be a wake-up call for Republicans. With a slim majority in the House of Representatives, GOP lawmakers may be starting to realize that relying on Trump to carry them to victory in 2024 might not be the safe bet they once thought it was. If these polling trends continue, it’s possible that Trump’s influence could have a negative impact on the party as a whole, making it harder for Republicans to hold onto key seats in Congress. With Democrats showing strong fundraising numbers, the 2024 race is shaping up to be more competitive than ever.
In the end, Trump’s second term is proving to be a turbulent ride, one that’s marked by shifting public opinion and growing dissatisfaction. Whether he can turn things around and regain his footing remains to be seen, but for now, the outlook doesn’t look great. For Republicans, the question is whether they’ll continue to back him or whether they’ll start to look for a new path forward.
Login