Former President Donald Trump recently made some bold statements about the current administration, adding to his ongoing criticism of President Joe Biden’s time in office. In an intense conversation with the Italian Prime Minister at the White House, Trump did not hold back, labeling Biden's leadership as the “worst” in the history of the United States. In fact, he went as far as to claim that former President Jimmy Carter, who passed away in December 2023, "died a happy man" knowing that his presidency was not as disastrous as Biden's. According to Trump, Carter would find solace in the fact that he wasn’t regarded as the worst president ever—a title that Trump firmly believes belongs to Biden.
This comment wasn’t an isolated incident. In fact, it’s part of a larger narrative Trump has been pushing for a while now. During the 2024 campaign trail, he repeatedly hammered home the idea that Joe Biden's administration has been a failure on numerous fronts. Trump’s criticisms of Biden have been hard-hitting, and this particular remark was a stark example of how far Trump is willing to go to make his point.
“He was useless. They were incompetent. Worst administration in the history of our country. Worse than Jimmy Carter,” Trump declared during a meeting with Italy's leader. His words were a part of his broader narrative about the state of American politics under the Biden administration. Trump didn't just stop at pointing out Biden’s shortcomings; he took it a step further by contrasting Biden's presidency with Carter’s, suggesting that even Carter, with all of his struggles, was a more competent leader. This line of attack is something that Trump has used multiple times, especially as the country has been grappling with economic struggles, rising inflation, and challenges with foreign policy.
In another poignant moment, Trump remarked, “Jimmy Carter died a happy man. You know why? Because he wasn’t the worst. President Joe Biden was.” These words are a part of Trump’s campaign messaging, where he often reflects on his vision of what a strong leader should look like in comparison to his political rivals. The jabs at Biden are not new, but they seem to be getting more pointed as Trump’s criticism becomes an integral part of his bid for the White House again in 2024.
Trump’s disdain for the current administration isn’t just about policy—it's personal. In January 2024, as Trump spoke at a rally, he reflected on attending the funeral of Rosalynn Carter, the wife of former President Jimmy Carter. “My wife attended the funeral two months ago of Rosalynn Carter, and it was beautiful, and Jimmy Carter was there,” Trump shared with his audience. His thoughts, however, were not just about the solemnity of the moment. He quickly segued into his belief that Carter, who had served as president from 1977 to 1981, would now go down in history as a "brilliant" president by comparison to Biden. “Jimmy Carter is happy now because he will go down as being a brilliant president by comparison to Joe Biden … He’s gonna be known as brilliant!” Trump said with his characteristic bravado.
Trump’s sentiments about Carter have been somewhat inconsistent in the past. While he has frequently criticized the former president, calling him "a terrible president" at times, there have also been moments of praise, particularly after a shared phone call between Trump and Carter regarding China in 2019. The praise was short-lived, though, as Trump later condemned Carter’s statements on Russian interference in the 2016 election, calling Carter's concerns “wrong” and dismissing them as a mere distraction.
Carter, who served as a one-term Democratic president, has often been the subject of mixed opinions in American politics. Some view his presidency as one marked by noble intentions but hindered by economic crises and foreign policy challenges, while others see him as a moral leader who worked tirelessly for peace, humanitarian efforts, and human rights. Regardless of where one falls on the spectrum, Carter’s legacy is undeniable—he was the only U.S. president to win the Nobel Peace Prize after leaving office, which speaks volumes about the influence he had on the world stage.
While Trump has focused on what he sees as Biden’s failures, Carter was also making waves in the political discourse during his final years. In a 2022 op-ed for The New York Times, Carter warned the American public about the state of democracy and the risks it faced in the upcoming elections. "Without immediate action, we are at genuine risk of civil conflict and losing our precious democracy," Carter wrote. His words were a call for unity, a stark warning about the fragile nature of democracy and the dangers of unchecked power. “Americans must set aside differences and work together before it is too late,” he urged.
The op-ed did not stop there, as Carter reflected on the broader political environment, drawing comparisons between America’s democratic challenges and the rise of authoritarian leaders around the world. He expressed grave concerns about the state of free elections, particularly the way in which "strongman politicians" were threatening to erode democratic processes not just in the U.S., but globally. "I now fear that what we have fought so hard to achieve globally—the right to free, fair elections, unhindered by strongman politicians who seek nothing more than to grow their own power—has become dangerously fragile at home," Carter warned.
Amidst all the political turmoil, one of the most heartwarming aspects of Carter’s final years was his ability to participate in the democratic process. As the nation mourned his passing at the age of 100, it was revealed that one of Carter’s last wishes was to vote for former Vice President Kamala Harris in the 2024 election. Despite his long tenure as a public servant, Carter was deeply committed to the idea of democratic participation and making his voice heard in the process. His final vote, for Harris, reflected his belief in the democratic ideals that he had championed throughout his life.
Notably, Carter outlived all other U.S. presidents, passing away just months before the election that would pit Biden against Trump in a rematch of the 2020 race. His passing marked the end of an era, but also left an indelible legacy that continues to influence discussions about American politics today. Many now look back on Carter’s presidency with a sense of nostalgia, recognizing his commitment to peace, human rights, and diplomacy.
As Trump continues to target Biden, his reflections on Carter serve as a reminder of how American presidents are often judged by history, and how public perception can shift over time. What’s clear is that Trump’s attempt to diminish Biden’s legacy by invoking Carter’s name is a reflection of his broader strategy to draw stark contrasts between his leadership style and that of his opponents. Whether or not this strategy resonates with voters will become clearer in the months leading up to the election, but one thing is for sure—Carter’s legacy will remain a key point of discussion in the ongoing political narrative.
Login