When Your Congressman Won’t Answer the Doorbell
Ever had that feeling where you're trying to reach someone — ringing, knocking, calling — but it's like nobody’s home? That’s exactly what’s been happening with U.S. Rep. Scott Perry lately.
Over the past couple of weeks, folks living in Perry’s central Pennsylvania district couldn’t even get someone to pick up the phone at any of his four offices. Even if you managed to show up in person, the scene wasn't much better. A locked door, an unanswered bell, and a voice from behind an intercom saying, “I don't have any public appearance information that I can provide.” Talk about frustrating!
And Perry’s team? Radio silence. They didn’t share any details about his public appearances until after they had already happened — making it almost impossible for voters to see him in action.
Where Are They Hiding?
It’s not just Perry ducking constituents. Across the country, especially in the most hotly contested districts — from Arizona to Wisconsin — some of the most vulnerable House Republicans have been playing a serious game of hide-and-seek during what’s called the “district work period.” That’s typically when lawmakers are supposed to be home, connecting with the very people who voted them into office.
Instead of facing potentially tough crowds or uncomfortable questions about President Trump’s early months back in office, many chose more "controlled" and quieter environments. Forget the good old-fashioned town hall — hardly any of them held in-person public events. One managed a telephone town hall, but most leaned into invitation-only gatherings with local officials, announced only after they were done and dusted.
And voters? They noticed.
“They're publicly elected officials. They ought to be accessible to the public,” said Robert Barton, a 57-year-old civil engineer, while grabbing a slice at Italian Delight Pizzeria — conveniently located right across the street from Perry’s locked-up Mechanicsburg office.
Controlled Exposure: The New Playbook
So what gives? Why the disappearing act?
According to veteran Republican strategist Doug Heye, there's method to this madness. In his words, "Interacting with constituents in planned and controlled ways is smarter for politicians.” Basically: limit the surprises, limit the viral disasters.
The National Republican Congressional Committee (NRCC) claims it's not telling lawmakers to hide. In fact, spokesperson Mike Marinella says, "We tell everyone, go out and meet people. You have to be in front of your constituents. Use every avenue you can."
But at the same time, there's clear caution in the air. House Speaker Mike Johnson even warned his colleagues that a lot of town hall attendees are "professional protesters." His advice? Skip the live confrontation. Try tele-town halls — big conference calls where thousands can listen, but questions are filtered.
History Lesson: Been There, Done That
If this all sounds familiar, that's because it is.
Back in 2010, Democrats — who were battling heat over the Affordable Care Act — started ducking public town halls after facing wild summer showdowns. Some even called rowdy protests “un-American.”
Fast forward a few years: When Republicans tried to repeal Obamacare in 2018, they also faced massive backlash. Then-House Speaker Paul Ryan basically said, “Nope, not doing town halls anymore,” to limit outside protesters.
Both times? The party that avoided constituents lost their House majority soon after.
The Democrats See an Opportunity
Democrats are wasting no time pouncing on the Republican ghost-town strategy.
With backing from the Democratic National Committee and big players like organized labor, they’ve rolled out a wave of “People’s Town Halls” and “Good Trouble” events — specifically in districts where Republicans are playing hard to get.
They're banking on the idea that voters will notice who’s showing up — and who’s hiding — by the time the 2026 midterms roll around. If Democrats can flip just two seats, they take back control of the House.
Michael Whatley, the Republican National Committee Chairman, put it bluntly while speaking to Iowa activists recently: “This midterm election cycle is going to determine whether we have a four-year presidency or a two-year presidency.”
Translation: If Republicans lose the House, President Trump’s last two years could be a total deadlock.
Snapshots From the Swing Districts
Take Iowa’s Mariannette Miller-Meeks, for example. She squeaked by last November with the narrowest win in the country — just 799 votes. You’d think she’d want to shake every hand she could find, right?
Not exactly.
During the Easter recess, Miller-Meeks stuck to tightly managed events like plant tours, small business meetings, a Rotary Club gathering, and a medical center groundbreaking. Most stops were only announced after they happened via her social media.
And like many of her fellow endangered Republicans? Not a single open-to-all town hall.
Meanwhile, Rep. Don Bacon over in Nebraska’s 2nd District kept things super low-key too. His social media featured a cozy Easter egg hunt in Omaha, but no big public events, no raucous town halls.
Back Home in Mechanicsburg: Frustration Grows
In Perry’s own backyard, voters and opponents are sharpening their focus.
Democratic challenger Janelle Stelson, a former TV broadcaster, isn’t holding back. After losing to Perry by just 5,000 votes last fall, she’s planning to take another swing at him in July.
"The job title is representative," Stelson pointed out. "It’s supposed to be about what your constituents care about — not about hiding from them."
And people are paying attention.
Mechanicsburg resident Tim Shollenberger, who recently left the Republican Party, tried participating in Perry’s April 2 tele-town hall. But the event wasn’t exactly a free-flowing conversation. Participants had to submit questions in writing — and none of Shollenberger’s three questions, including some on Social Security and Perry’s accessibility, made it through.
His takeaway? “If you really care about your constituents’ views, get in a room and face them.”
Final Thought: Voters Aren't Forgetting
Whether it’s locked office doors, hidden schedules, or phone lines ringing into the void, voters across these key swing districts are taking notes.
Public service isn’t just about party loyalty or political strategy. It’s about showing up. Facing tough questions. Listening — even when it’s uncomfortable.
In politics, just like in life, sometimes the bravest thing you can do is simply open the door.
Login