The buzz surrounding Detroit Tigers manager A.J. Hinch is undeniable as he's recognized as one of the finalists for the prestigious 2024 American League Manager of the Year Award. Nominated by the Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA), Hinch stands alongside two other contenders, Cleveland Guardians’ Stephen Vogt and Kansas City Royals’ Matt Quatraro. All three managers hail from the American League Central, making it a highly competitive field this year. The Tigers, under Hinch's leadership, finished the season with an impressive 86-76 record, claiming third place in the division. Even more remarkable? Detroit’s win count jumped by eight games from the prior season—a testament to the growth and perseverance the team has shown.
Reflecting on the season, Hinch took a humble approach when speaking on MLB Network, acknowledging that the team’s success is largely due to a deep player commitment and a dedicated coaching staff. "It has to start with the player buy-in and my coaching staff," he shared. "You need both of those things to be good at this job and to lead a team as the manager. ... My staff and the players, they were incredible this year and made my job as fun as it can get in this seat." Such words highlight his appreciation for the team effort and the chemistry that propelled the Tigers forward.
Why Hinch Deserves This Recognition
A.J. Hinch’s managerial prowess is not new to the league, but capturing this award would be an official testament to his hard work and strategic genius. Despite receiving Manager of the Year votes multiple times in his career, he’s yet to secure the title. His closest shot came in 2015, finishing second, followed by a third-place finish in 2017 and additional top-ten finishes in 2019 and 2021. Winning this year would also make him the first Tigers manager to claim the title since Jim Leyland did in 2006. Legendary Tigers managers like Sparky Anderson, who won the award in 1984 and 1987, have paved the way, and Hinch now has the opportunity to join these Hall of Fame-caliber names.
This season wasn’t just about grinding through games. The Tigers’ journey to the playoffs marked the end of a nine-year postseason drought, bringing excitement back to Detroit fans. Players thrived under Hinch’s guidance, where his chess-like strategies with pinch-hitters, and the use of openers and bulk relievers, brought a fresh dynamic to the team’s approach. Hinch’s tactical acumen, combined with a roster willing to go the extra mile, created a potent blend that has now earned him this honor.
Highlighting the Season’s Key Moments
One of the highlights of Detroit’s season was their remarkable 31-13 record in the final 44 games. This impressive stretch solidified their reputation as one of the strongest teams in baseball, not just in September but throughout the latter half of the season. For Hinch, it was all about building a culture where each game counted and the team mentality centered on winning every night. "Our guys really bought into trying to win every night," he explained, noting that the team’s dedication allowed them to pull off one of the most successful stretches in recent Tigers history.
The Tigers showcased an unmatched level of buy-in, embracing Hinch’s strategies without hesitation. Whether it was a player walking off the on-deck circle because of a pinch-hitter or pitchers stepping off the mound for a reliever with a specialized role, they trusted Hinch’s calls without question. This unshakable trust didn’t happen overnight—it’s something that Hinch and his coaching staff worked hard to instill. “That type of buy-in isn’t free,” Hinch remarked. “You’ve got to build that over time, and you need staff to reinforce that, and you need to execute at a high level.” This culture of trust and commitment became the bedrock of their successful season.
How Hinch and His Team Shaped a Winning Culture
A key reason for Detroit’s surge was the focus on small victories. Hinch instilled a mindset where the team wasn’t merely looking at the standings but taking things game-by-game, week-by-week. The Tigers saw that consistent success over 50-60 games was within reach if they trusted each other and focused on execution. This strategy paid off as their confidence surged, and their gameplay only improved under the spotlight.
During the latter half of the season, the Tigers were playing some of the best baseball in the league. The pressure was on, yet the team rose to the occasion, showcasing resilience and determination. As the fanbase grew louder and the media attention increased, the players responded by elevating their performances. "We had no margin for error to get where we got," Hinch noted, highlighting the grit that powered Detroit to stay competitive. “But we kept winning games and winning series and winning weeks.” That perseverance has become synonymous with this season's Tigers and has fans hopeful for an even brighter future.
Could This Be Hinch’s Year?
On November 19, at 6 p.m. on MLB Network, the winner of the American League Manager of the Year Award will be announced. As Detroit fans await the results, there’s plenty of excitement and pride for how far the team has come. In just four seasons with the Tigers, Hinch has guided them from a team struggling to find its footing to one that’s breaking records and making waves. His current record with Detroit stands at 307-341, reflecting the strides they’ve made each year: 77 wins in 2021, 66 in 2022, 78 in 2023, and now, 86 wins in 2024.
For Hinch, this year’s nomination is not just about personal achievement—it’s a nod to the collective effort of the entire Tigers organization. It’s also a milestone that signifies the Tigers' re-emergence as a force in the league. "This wasn’t just a good September," Hinch shared. "This was a good second half of the season to get where we got. The attention that we got as it grew, our players started to play better and better." Such sentiments resonate with the fans and the team alike, demonstrating that Detroit is indeed on an upward trajectory.
Why This Season Mattered to Detroit
For a city like Detroit, which prides itself on resilience and grit, the Tigers' success this season has been especially meaningful. After years of waiting, fans have been rewarded with a team that doesn’t just show up but shows heart, game after game. The Tigers’ success under Hinch’s guidance has instilled a sense of renewed hope and energy in the Motor City. A Manager of the Year win for Hinch would be a fitting recognition of the commitment and passion he’s brought to the Tigers, both on and off the field.
In many ways, Hinch has set the foundation for what could be the start of a new era for Detroit baseball. Whether or not he takes home the Manager of the Year Award, there’s no doubt that he’s earned his place in Tigers history. Detroit fans have reason to look forward to more thrilling seasons ahead, and Hinch’s impact will continue to echo in every game played at Comerica Park.
Summary of Key Points:
- Hinch’s Recognition: A.J. Hinch is a finalist for the 2024 AL Manager of the Year.
- Historic Season: The Tigers finished 86-76, ending a nine-year postseason drought.
- Strategic Mastery: Hinch’s effective use of pinch-hitters and relievers demonstrated a fresh, effective approach.
- Remarkable Stretch: Detroit finished 31-13 in their final 44 games, showcasing their potential.
- Looking Ahead: Hinch’s nomination symbolizes the Tigers' resurgence and the city’s renewed baseball spirit.
Come November 19, the baseball world will be watching, but regardless of the outcome, Hinch and the Tigers have already won something priceless: the hearts of Detroit fans.
Login