Amani Toomer Sounds the Alarm on Giants' Culture: "Change Everything"
The New York Giants might have just wrapped up another NFL season, but former wide receiver Amani Toomer isn’t letting them off the hook. Shortly after Super Bowl LIX, Toomer came out swinging, calling out the franchise for what he sees as a massive culture problem—and he's not wrong.
While the Giants’ struggles have been evident for years, Toomer took particular offense at Michael Strahan waving the Philadelphia Eagles flag. Toomer didn't see it as just a fun moment; he called it a "warning shot"—a sign that the franchise's decline is being noticed by its own legends. And for Toomer, the warning couldn't be more justified.
The Harsh Reality: Giants' Failures Speak for Themselves
Toomer isn’t interested in sugarcoating the state of the Giants. In a candid interview with Pat Leonard of the New York Daily News, he made it clear that his criticism isn’t personal—it’s professional. He’s not looking for drama; he’s demanding results.
“I love Brian Daboll, and I love Joe Schoen,” Toomer admitted. “But at the end of the day, this is not a personality contest. This is a results business, and the results just aren’t there. It’s not personal. I don’t hate these guys. I just want the results. It’s like, ‘Show me the baby.’ Show me something to be proud of.”
Accountability Starts at the Top
What frustrates Toomer the most is the apparent comfort level in the Giants' front office and locker room. He believes no one should feel at ease given the team’s poor performance over the last two seasons.
“There should be nobody comfortable in that building,” he emphasized. “I know the owner’s not happy. I know that for a fact. I know that the front office isn’t happy.”
So, if ownership and management are upset, why hasn’t there been a bigger shake-up?
The Culture Problem Runs Deep
Toomer points to a glaring issue with effort and accountability on the field. He didn’t name names, but he hinted that there are players simply not giving their best.
“We have a corner out there who’s not— we have somebody out there, I’m not gonna say any names—who’s not putting forth effort,” Toomer said. “That is the basics of winning. How do you not play with effort in the NFL? That’s one of two things: either they’re not holding him accountable, or the team isn’t deep enough to where you have a real fear of losing your position every day of the week.”
That lack of fear, that sense of security despite underperformance, is what kills teams. If players don’t feel like they have to fight for their jobs, then complacency sets in—and that, Toomer warns, is a recipe for disaster.
The Roster Mismanagement is Alarming
One of the most frustrating aspects of the Giants' current situation, according to Toomer, is the way they’ve handled their roster. Under general manager Joe Schoen, the team has let multiple captains and Pro Bowlers walk away without much resistance. That decision-making, Toomer says, speaks volumes about the organization’s priorities.
“We let three Pro Bowlers out of our building: [Xavier] McKinney, Saquon [Barkley], and [Leonard] Williams. We let them just go,” Toomer pointed out. “And I’m sure there’s more of them: Evan Engram, even [Sterling] Shepard played well. [Julian] Love. That’s a cultural problem.”
And he takes it a step further—suggesting that even drafting an elite player like Patrick Mahomes wouldn’t solve anything if the culture remains broken.
“You can draft whoever you want. We could have drafted Patrick Mahomes. If that culture is not there, that’s a big problem.”
What’s the Fix? Burn it Down and Start Over
Toomer is clear: the only way forward is radical change.
“You’ve got to change everything,” he said bluntly. “The way you practice, everything, so there’s nothing similar from last year. Comfortability kills teams. And if they feel comfortable, raise the bar of expectations to the point where if you don’t want to become part of this team, it becomes brutally honest.”
That means new expectations, new energy, and a complete overhaul in how things are done. If players aren’t willing to push themselves every single day, they shouldn’t be part of the team.
But Will Anything Actually Change?
Here’s the problem: despite Toomer’s warning, the Giants don’t seem to be doing much about it. So far this offseason, the front office and coaching staff have remained mostly unchanged. If the people running the show stay the same, how much can really improve?
Toomer’s message is clear—Giants fans deserve better. The team needs a wake-up call, and if the organization doesn’t listen, the franchise could stay stuck in mediocrity for years to come. Giants Nation, are you ready for real change, or are we in for more of the same?
Login