Bartolo Colón at 52? Big Sexy Teases MLB Comeback and Fans Go Wild

Bartolo Colón at 52? Yep, He's Still Thinking About It—and Fans Are Eating It Up

At an age when most former Major League Baseball players are sipping cocktails on a golf course or cashing checks for TV studio work, Bartolo Colón is out here playfully tossing his name back into the big leagues. And honestly? The internet can’t get enough of it.

Let’s rewind a bit. On a quiet Friday, out of nowhere, the 2005 Cy Young Award winner took to Twitter/X and responded to a pretty harmless question from SNY—the New York Mets' regional sports network. The post asked, “If you could add one former Met to the current roster, who would you pick?”

Colón, in true Big Sexy fashion, didn’t hesitate to reply with a wink and a nudge:

“I might still have something left in the tank.”

And just like that, the idea of a 52-year-old Bartolo Colón making a comeback went from laughable to—wait, is this actually happening?

🧢 The Legend of "Big Sexy" Lives On

If there’s one thing Colón mastered during his 21-year MLB career, it’s showmanship. Sure, his stats were solid—he racked up 247 career wins and over 2,500 strikeouts—but it was his lovable, everyman aura that turned him into a cult hero. The dude hit one home run his entire career, and it instantly became one of the greatest moments in baseball history. No joke.

And now, years after he last took the mound, fans are still obsessed.

Seriously—how many pitchers retire, fade into the sunset, and then get invited back into the national conversation like this?

🚨 Let’s Talk Comebacks: Is This Even Realistic?

Let’s keep it 100 here. Bartolo hasn’t thrown a pitch in the majors since September 2018, when he was wrapping things up with the Minnesota Twins. That year, he posted a 7-12 record with a 5.78 ERA across 28 appearances (24 of them starts). He logged 146.1 innings, which isn’t too shabby for someone pushing the mid-40s.

But 52?

That's entering freak-of-nature territory.

For comparison, Jamie Moyer pitched until he was 49 and became the oldest pitcher ever to record a win in the majors. And even that felt like witnessing a unicorn gallop across a diamond.

Only seven players in history have taken the field past the age of 50, and let’s be honest—at least one of those appearances was purely a publicity stunt.

⚾ What’s the Real Motivation Here?

Let’s not read too much into it—Colón probably isn’t doing long toss every morning waiting for a team to call. This is more of a “wouldn’t it be funny if...” kind of moment. But even that’s enough to spark excitement among baseball die-hards.

And don’t forget: Bartolo’s not just any retired pitcher. He played for 11 different MLB teams. That’s 11 fanbases that could potentially rally behind a return. Can you imagine the buzz if the Cleveland Guardians, his original squad, picked him up for one more go-around?

They’re currently sitting at 44-48. Not great, not terrible. Maybe not playoff-bound, but a team with nothing to lose. If they’re not going to make a serious run at another postseason miracle like their 2024 ALCS appearance, why not make headlines by signing a fan-favorite for one final game?

Give the people what they want.

💸 Why the Mets Probably Aren’t Calling

As much as Mets fans might adore Bartolo—and they do, trust us—he probably won’t be donning blue and orange again anytime soon. The 2025 Mets roster is loaded with over $320 million in salary commitments. That’s not exactly “let’s bring in Big Sexy for a feel-good moment” money.

Plus, they're in the thick of the playoff hunt, trailing the Phillies by just 1.5 games. That leaves little room for nostalgia and more pressure for results.

But hey, never say never. Stranger things have happened. And a ceremonial one-day contract wouldn’t be out of the question if the Mets really wanted to give the fans a moment.

🏟️ More Than Just a Comeback—It’s a Vibe

Here’s the thing—whether he pitches again or not, Bartolo Colón continues to be the vibe. There’s a reason his name trends every few months. There’s a reason thousands of fans responded with heart emojis, gifs, and hopeful messages when he teased his return.

He represents something rare in sports: joy. Pure, uncomplicated joy. He didn’t have the chiseled physique. He didn’t throw 102 mph. But man, did he bring the fun.

That’s why his response hit so hard. It wasn’t just about baseball—it was about nostalgia. About a time when fans could watch a game and see a guy out there who looked like your uncle at a family BBQ… only he was striking out MVPs.

🔥 5 Reasons Fans Would Lose It If Bartolo Returned

1. Big Sexy Merch Sales – You know people would buy those jerseys in a heartbeat.

2. One Last At-Bat – Even if it’s just ceremonial, who wouldn’t want to see him swing for the fences one more time?

3. Social Media Would Explode – Colón memes, gifs, highlight reels—Twitter would melt down.

4. Feel-Good Factor – It’s a reminder that baseball isn’t just about stats. It’s about stories.

5. He Might Still Have It – Okay, maybe not ace level stuff. But a scoreless inning? Don’t rule it out.

👀 What’s Next?

Right now, it’s just a tweet. A single line that sent a wave of excitement across baseball Twitter. But that’s all it takes when you’re Bartolo Colón.

Whether or not he ever touches a mound again, he already cemented his legacy—not just as a reliable pitcher, but as a cultural icon in the game.

And let’s be real—if he does find himself back on a mound, even for one inning, it’ll be the biggest story of the season.

Until then, Big Sexy is exactly where he’s always been: living rent-free in the hearts of baseball fans everywhere.