The Dallas Cowboys and Pittsburgh Steelers, two iconic franchises in NFL history, are once again grappling with playoff frustrations. Both teams failed to secure a playoff win this season, extending their long Super Bowl droughts. While fans continue to hope for a breakthrough, a bold idea from a Dallas legend might offer both teams the shake-up they need to get back on track.
Former Cowboys head coach Jimmy Johnson stirred the pot during Fox’s pregame show with a thought-provoking suggestion. “Things are stale in Pittsburgh, things are stale in Dallas,” he said. “Food for thought. How about a coaching swap? Mike McCarthy’s a Pittsburgh guy. Let him go to Pittsburgh. Let Mike Tomlin go to Dallas.” Now, that’s a proposition to get fans talking! Imagine the ripple effects of such a swap—it’s a scenario that’s as exciting as it is unconventional.
Mike McCarthy’s future with the Cowboys has been a topic of heated discussion. His current contract is set to expire, but reports suggest that McCarthy and Cowboys owner Jerry Jones are already discussing a new deal. NFL Network’s Tom Pelissero revealed that McCarthy’s return for the 2025 season is highly likely, a surprising turn of events given the team’s struggles earlier in the season. From mid-October to mid-November, the Cowboys endured a painful five-game losing streak. Despite these setbacks, the team managed to win four of their final seven games, showing resilience in the face of adversity, including injuries to key players like quarterback Dak Prescott. Jerry Jones even praised McCarthy’s ability to steer the team through tough times, a testament to his coaching under pressure.
Meanwhile, the Pittsburgh Steelers face their own set of challenges. Mike Tomlin, who has been at the helm since 2007, is under increasing scrutiny. While Tomlin’s record of never having a losing season is impressive, the Steelers have struggled to make a deep playoff run in recent years. Their 10-7 record this season ended with a disappointing Wild Card loss to the Baltimore Ravens, marking the second consecutive year they’ve been eliminated in the opening round. Even more frustrating for Steelers fans, the team has gone eight seasons without a playoff win, compiling an 0-5 record in that stretch.
Tomlin’s playoff woes are starting to overshadow his regular-season success. With eight one-and-done playoff appearances, he’s inching closer to tying former Kansas City Chiefs head coach Marty Schottenheimer’s record of nine. Despite this, the Steelers are reportedly planning to stick with Tomlin for the 2025 season. According to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Gerry Dulac, the organization remains committed to their long-time coach, even as frustration mounts among fans.
So, what if Johnson’s idea of a coaching swap became reality? Let’s break it down:
-
Mike McCarthy in Pittsburgh: McCarthy’s blue-collar roots and ties to Pittsburgh could make him a natural fit for the Steelers’ culture. His offensive expertise might provide the spark the team needs to rejuvenate their roster and develop a more dynamic game plan.
-
Mike Tomlin in Dallas: Tomlin’s no-nonsense leadership style and defensive acumen could be just what the Cowboys need to instill discipline and grit. Dallas has long been criticized for underperforming in critical moments, and Tomlin’s track record of consistency could help them overcome that hurdle.
While the chances of a coaching swap actually happening are slim, the concept itself highlights a larger issue: both teams might benefit from fresh perspectives. Staleness can creep into even the most storied franchises, and sometimes a change at the top can reignite the fire.
The Cowboys and Steelers are more than just football teams—they’re institutions. Both boast passionate fan bases that expect nothing less than championship glory. Yet, year after year, these teams fall short of the ultimate goal. Could a dramatic move like swapping coaches be the key to breaking their Super Bowl droughts? It’s an intriguing thought, one that invites debate and speculation.
At the end of the day, whether or not McCarthy and Tomlin switch places, both franchises need to address their stagnation. For Dallas, that might mean bolstering their roster and addressing persistent injury issues. For Pittsburgh, it could involve rethinking their offensive strategy and finding ways to maximize their talent. One thing is certain: neither team can afford to continue down the same path and expect different results.
As fans, we can only wait and see what the future holds for these legendary teams. Will they make bold moves to turn things around, or will they stick with the status quo and risk further disappointment? Only time will tell, but one thing’s for sure—the pressure is on, and the stakes have never been higher.
Login