Dillon Thieneman's departure from Purdue football is a gut punch for the program, but it’s also a reminder of the inevitable crossroads every player must face. For years, Thieneman embodied the spirit and legacy of the Boilermakers like few others—his family’s deep ties to Purdue, his stunning freshman season, and the promise of greatness. Yet, despite the emotional connection, family history, and loyalty, even the strongest ties can’t keep a player tethered when a bigger opportunity knocks.
On Saturday, Thieneman announced he was committing to the No. 1 playoff seed, Oregon, out of the transfer portal. This move follows a promising start to his college career, marked by a breakout freshman season where he was one of the nation’s top performers in interceptions. His freshman year against Fresno State, where he snagged an interception, felt like a statement to both fans and scouts that a future star had arrived. However, the reality of his departure leaves Boilermaker fans pondering what might have been and what could still lie ahead for the program.
While the departure of players like Nic Scourton and Deion Burks to other programs last winter may have already stung, Thieneman’s exit stings in a different way. It doesn’t come down to just money, NIL deals, or a more well-funded program. His departure highlights an even deeper issue—a systemic instability within Purdue football that’s now threatening the program's future.
A Legacy of Loyalty and Family Ties
To understand Thieneman’s impact at Purdue, you have to look at his family’s influence on his journey. His brothers, Jake and Brennan, both walked the same path before him, each rising from walk-ons to key starters on the team. Their success story wasn’t just a source of inspiration for Dillon—it was a defining feature of his Boilermaker legacy. Thieneman’s loyalty to Purdue wasn’t just about staying close to family. It was about honoring that deep-rooted connection to the program, which transcended typical expectations. But as his career unfolded, the harsh reality set in: Thieneman, despite his incredible potential, couldn’t carry the weight of Purdue's struggles alone.
Despite a standout freshman year that placed him in national conversation, Thieneman stayed loyal to the program in 2024, even when other top programs circled. Oregon, Ohio State, and others recognized his value, and some even reached out to see if he might be interested in a change of scenery. But Thieneman chose to stay in West Lafayette, motivated by loyalty, a desire to build something lasting under coach Ryan Walters, and a bit of pride in rejecting programs that had previously overlooked him as a high school prospect. Unfortunately, that decision didn’t work out the way anyone had hoped.
The 2024 season was a nightmare for the Boilermakers, with the team finishing 1-11, an embarrassing and demoralizing record that shattered any semblance of momentum the program had hoped to build. Thieneman’s own performance mirrored this decline. After an explosive freshman year with six interceptions, he failed to register any in his sophomore season. What started as a promising career turned into a year of frustration, as missed tackles and poor angles became the hallmark of his play. Thieneman, once hailed as a rising star, found himself almost functioning as a scapegoat for a defense that couldn’t keep up with the increasing pressure from opposing offenses.
Despite these setbacks, Thieneman never wavered in his belief that the team had the potential to turn things around. In a conversation with him on Oct. 23, he spoke not with bitterness or frustration, but with optimism about Purdue’s future. "We've shown stints where we can go out there and we can play with anyone," Thieneman said. "But we just got to put it all together. People see that we can go out there, we can play. Everyone's just gotta be on the same page."
A Reality Check for the Program
As much as Purdue fans wish they could hold on to the dream of keeping Thieneman for another season, reality doesn’t always play out that way. The truth is, no amount of loyalty or love for Purdue could offset the competitive disadvantages that players like Thieneman face when they compare their current situation to what’s available at programs like Oregon.
It’s easy to get lost in the allure of money, name, image, and likeness deals, but the real contrast comes in the resources, facilities, and overall opportunity for success. If you were in Thieneman’s shoes and had one more shot at college football, where would you go? Would you stay at a program that’s struggling to climb out of the bottom of the Big Ten, or would you join a national title contender like Oregon, with the best resources and an established pathway to postseason success?
If the financial disparity weren’t an issue, Thieneman’s decision might have been a bit more complicated. But when you’re facing a future at Purdue that’s clouded by uncertainty, a coaching change, and an upcoming brutal schedule, it’s hard to justify staying when a golden opportunity like Oregon presents itself. Purdue’s struggles are not just limited to this season. Even with a new coach in Barry Odom, the program will have to undergo what Odom himself describes as a "rebuild" if they’re to have any hope of competing in the Big Ten.
The Big Ten Struggles and the Talent Drain
In 2024, Purdue's schedule is a daunting one, featuring powerhouse teams that reached the College Football Playoff, as well as others who were competitive at the highest levels of college football. A team coming off a 1-11 season, with few signs of immediate improvement, is not an attractive destination for players looking to compete at a championship level.
Oregon, on the other hand, is a powerhouse in college football with everything a player like Thieneman could want: elite facilities, national championship aspirations, and a real chance to play on the biggest stage in college sports. The Ducks aren’t just a contender—they’re one of the favorites to win the first-ever 12-team playoff. Given the chance to join a program with such a strong, consistent track record, Thieneman’s decision becomes all the more understandable.
This departure isn’t just about Thieneman; it’s a symptom of a larger issue plaguing Purdue football. The talent drain that Purdue is facing is real. Other players, like defensive end Will Heldt and tight end Max Klare, are also attracting attention from top-tier programs like LSU, Clemson, and others. These athletes are weighing the same question: Do they stay with Purdue, or do they chase success at a program that can deliver on its promises of championship football?
The Boilermakers' Future
For Purdue football, the departure of Thieneman and others marks a critical turning point. As much as the Boilermakers might mourn the loss of a player with such deep ties to the program, they have to face the fact that success in college football is a long game, and stability starts with winning. Purdue can’t afford to keep sliding in the Big Ten rankings, and the only way to stop the talent exodus is to build a program that’s competitive, stable, and capable of winning.
The Boilermakers’ future may be bright, but it’s going to require a lot of work, dedication, and, most importantly, winning. If Odom and the Purdue administration can fix the on-field struggles, they might be able to close the talent drain. But until then, players like Thieneman will continue to look for better opportunities, both financially and competitively.
As for Thieneman, his legacy at Purdue will be remembered with pride, but also with the bittersweet knowledge that the program’s struggles ultimately cost them one of their most talented players. Let’s hope Purdue learns from this and takes the necessary steps to ensure that the next wave of talent doesn’t slip through the cracks.
Login