When you're trying to earn the starting goalkeeper spot for your country ahead of the biggest soccer tournament in the world, you expect the road to be rocky. For USMNT’s 26-year-old keeper Matt Freese, it’s been a little more than that. His Gold Cup journey has been a mix of high-pressure moments, teachable missteps, and the kind of growth coaches love to see.
Let’s rewind to one of the most dramatic moments of the tournament so far. It’s the 19th minute of the USA’s final group stage match against Haiti. The score’s 1-0 in favor of the U.S., and everything seems under control—until it wasn’t. Veteran defender Tim Ream, under pressure deep in his own half, played a back pass to Freese. Haitian striker Louicius Don Deedson was lurking, and Freese mishandled the clearance. In a heartbeat, Deedson pounced and leveled the score.
Ouch.
Freese didn’t sugarcoat it afterward: “It’s probably a moment to be smart, be safe and put it out,” he told reporters. But here’s the twist: the U.S. rallied and came back to win 2-1, securing the top spot in Group D. It was a lesson in resilience—something that could serve Freese well if he wants to cement himself as the starting keeper for the 2026 World Cup.
🧤 The Big Question: Freese or Turner?
This Gold Cup has sparked a fascinating subplot within the U.S. camp—who should be the man between the posts? Freese or Matt Turner?
Turner, the starter at the 2022 World Cup in Qatar, has been the established No. 1 for a while now. But a lack of playing time with Crystal Palace this past season has opened a window of opportunity. Freese, who entered the tournament without a single senior cap, has suddenly become a legitimate contender.
Let’s not forget how this run started. Freese made his USMNT debut in a pre-Gold Cup friendly against Turkiye, which ended in a 2-1 loss. He then watched from the bench as Turner started in a 4-0 defeat to Switzerland. But when manager Mauricio Pochettino (yes, that Mauricio Pochettino) handed him the starting nod against Trinidad and Tobago in the Gold Cup opener, he made it clear the pressure was off.
"Just be yourself, that’s all you have to do," Pochettino told him. “We’re putting you in there for a reason.”
🤝 A Healthy Rivalry
While goalkeeper battles can often turn icy, this one’s been anything but. Freese describes his relationship with Turner as “a very healthy competition.”
“Matt and I are very close,” he said. “We know it’s our job to push each other at the right times and support each other when needed. He’s an incredible goalkeeper and a great teammate. It’s very clear he has my back—and I’d absolutely have his.”
The mutual respect between the two netminders is a key reason why this competition has been positive rather than divisive. For a team looking to develop chemistry heading into a home World Cup, that kind of dynamic can’t be overstated.
💡 Coaching with Compassion
Pochettino has earned praise for how he’s handled this competition—particularly with Freese, who’s still getting his feet wet at this level. According to Freese, the Argentine coach starts conversations on a personal level before pivoting to tactics and instruction.
“He does a really good job relating to the players,” Freese said. “It starts out friendly, then becomes more about soccer. Nothing’s forced.”
And when it comes to mistakes like the one against Haiti, Pochettino wasn’t rattled.
“Remember, the most important action is the next one,” he reportedly told Freese. “If you focus on the last one, you’re going to make another mistake. These things happen.”
🧱 Building a Case for the World Cup
Freese has started all three Gold Cup matches so far—a 5-0 rout of Trinidad and Tobago, a narrow 1-0 win over Saudi Arabia, and the bounce-back 2-1 victory over Haiti. Next up? A quarterfinal showdown against Costa Rica (Sunday, 7 p.m. ET, FOX).
Whether Pochettino sticks with Freese or brings back the more experienced Turner is still a mystery. So far, the manager hasn’t shown much appetite for altering his starting lineups, which could suggest Freese keeps his spot—at least for one more match.
But long-term, the stakes are massive. With the 2026 World Cup on home soil, every minute Freese plays could tip the balance in his favor. Asked if he considers himself the frontrunner to be the USMNT’s starting keeper in 2026, Freese didn’t bite.
“It’s not at the forefront of my mind,” he said. “What I’m focused on is that each new game is another opportunity. We have a big one coming up this weekend.”
🔍 Behind the Numbers and Beyond
Stats don’t always tell the whole story, but they help. Freese hasn’t conceded many goals this tournament—just two over three matches. His distribution has been solid (aside from the hiccup vs. Haiti), and his command of the box has improved with each outing.
More importantly, his presence seems to elevate the backline. Ream and others have looked comfortable playing the ball back to him, even under pressure.
🚀 What’s Next?
If the U.S. gets past Costa Rica, a semifinal rematch with Panama or Jamaica could await. And if they keep winning? A likely final against arch-rival Mexico looms large. That matchup could be pivotal not just for the trophy, but for the final verdict on Freese’s role moving forward.
One thing’s for sure—this summer has been transformative for Matt Freese. From unknown squad member to legitimate starter, his evolution has been both rapid and impressive.
🔥 Key Takeaways:
-
Freese’s Mistake = Growth Opportunity: That Haiti game might end up defining his mental toughness more than his technical skill.
-
Pochettino’s Trust Is Real: The coach has backed Freese consistently and views this as a critical testing ground.
-
Turner vs. Freese Isn’t Toxic: These guys are genuinely rooting for each other, which is rare and refreshing.
-
World Cup 2026 Watch Begins Now: Every decision from this Gold Cup could impact the roster for next summer’s big stage.
Login