A New Chapter for NHL: Coyotes' Move to Salt Lake City and the Uncertainty of Their Return to Arizona
The announcement that the Phoenix Coyotes franchise would be relocating to Salt Lake City, Utah in April marked a significant shift in the NHL landscape. This move dashed the slim hopes of the league returning to Arizona, hopes that were largely tied to a pivotal land auction slated for the following Thursday. Unfortunately, those hopes took another hit when the auction was abruptly cancelled on Friday.
The Arizona State Land Department (ASLD) pulled the 110-acre site at the northwest corner of the Loop 101 Freeway and Scottsdale Road from the auction block. This site was integral to Coyotes owner Alex Meruelo's ambitious vision of an "entertainment district." The district was set to include a state-of-the-art NHL arena, a practice facility, a live music theater, office spaces, restaurants, retail outlets, and 1,900 luxury residential units.
However, in a statement, the ASLD detailed their reasoning: “After much consideration, the Arizona State Land Department has determined that it is in the best interest of the Trust to cancel the auction and reorder the steps. ASLD recently confirmed that the proposed arena use will require a Special Use Permit, and as a result, we are requesting that the applicant file for and receive a Special Use Permit prior to the auction. This affords the applicant and ASLD certainty that the applicant can build what it intends to build for its anchor tenant. It is not uncommon for ASLD to require applicants to secure zoning/use permits prior to auction.”
This decision, while rooted in procedural prudence, has significant implications for the future of NHL hockey in Arizona. The Coyotes' statement on social media highlighted their frustration and the potential ramifications of this delay: "This unprecedented action by the State of Arizona seriously jeopardizes the future of NHL hockey returning to the desert. The Arizona Coyotes are exploring all our legal options given this shortsighted decision by the state."
Meruelo's frustration is understandable, especially given the timeline and the stakes involved. The Phoenix Business Journal noted that Meruelo's intention was to purchase land that wouldn’t require any zoning changes or actions needing city council approval, which could then be subjected to a public referendum. This approach was influenced by the team's previous experience in Tempe, where a public vote in 2023 derailed another arena project.
The decision to require a Special Use Permit adds a layer of complexity and uncertainty to the process. This requirement means Meruelo must secure the permit before even bidding on the land, a significant hurdle given the Coyotes' recent history and the urgency of their situation.
Despite the setback, the Coyotes aren't completely out of options. NHL deputy commissioner Bill Daly stated that Meruelo has a five-year window to acquire land and complete 50 percent of an arena to retain the right to place a new Coyotes franchise in Phoenix. This timeframe provides a glimmer of hope, but the path forward is fraught with challenges.
According to gophnx.com, Meruelo had also been exploring other potential sites. He had a letter of intent for a site in Mesa and at least one other location. However, similar to the Scottsdale site, these alternatives also face zoning hurdles that must be addressed before any arena construction can proceed.
In the interim, the former Coyotes franchise is set to debut in Salt Lake City next season under a new name. Meruelo, however, retains the right to bring an expansion team back to Arizona, provided he can secure a permanent facility. This caveat underscores the importance of finding a viable site for a new arena, a task that now requires navigating additional bureaucratic and legal steps.
The cancellation of the auction and the requirement for a Special Use Permit underscore the intricate interplay between real estate, local governance, and professional sports. For Meruelo and the Coyotes, the road ahead involves not just finding the right piece of land but also ensuring that all regulatory and zoning requirements are met. This meticulous process is critical to avoid repeating past missteps and ensuring that any future arena project has a solid foundation.
Key Points to Consider:
- Cancellation of the Auction: The decision by ASLD to cancel the auction and require a Special Use Permit was a significant blow to the Coyotes' plans.
- Meruelo’s Vision: The proposed entertainment district was more than just an arena; it was a comprehensive development plan aimed at revitalizing the area.
- Legal and Procedural Hurdles: The necessity of securing zoning and use permits prior to auction is a common but crucial step that adds complexity to the project.
- Future of NHL in Arizona: Despite the current setbacks, there remains a window of opportunity for bringing NHL hockey back to Arizona, contingent on meeting specific criteria within the next five years.
- Exploring Alternatives: Meruelo's exploration of other sites, including those in Mesa, highlights the ongoing search for a viable location for a new arena.
In conclusion, while the immediate future of NHL hockey in Arizona is uncertain, the efforts and negotiations surrounding the Coyotes' arena plans highlight the broader challenges and intricacies involved in professional sports franchises finding a permanent home. The outcome of these efforts will have lasting implications for the sport's presence in the desert state.
Login