Right-hander Gerrit Cole has decided to stay with the New York Yankees, sticking with his original four-year, $144 million deal, despite triggering an opt-out clause last Saturday. This decision, announced by the Yankees late on Monday, leaves Yankees fans breathing a sigh of relief, as Cole will continue to be a central figure on the team’s pitching staff. Originally, Cole had the option to become a free agent unless the Yankees added a fifth year to his contract, effectively making it a $180 million, five-year deal. However, despite declining that addition, the Yankees still managed to work out an agreement, treating the opt-out as if it hadn’t happened.
In the words of Yankees GM Brian Cashman, "It was something at the moment we weren't necessarily comfortable doing, but we wanted our player and our ace back, and he certainly didn’t want to go either at the same time." Cashman’s words, shared at the general manager’s meetings in Texas, reflect the dedication on both sides to finding common ground and keeping Cole in New York. It’s clear that the Yankees valued their ace too much to let him go.
The back-and-forth discussions between Cole and the Yankees lasted well beyond the typical deadline. Initially, the two parties had until Sunday to reach a decision, but the deadline was extended to Monday evening as the conversations continued. Cashman revealed that a mixture of factors contributed to the extra time, including the tight timeline of the offseason, especially with the World Series ending only days before. "It feels like he legitimately just got off the mound, and we were in our discussions," Cashman said, describing the rapid turnaround from postseason action to contract negotiations. This extra time allowed for thoughtful dialogue, rather than forcing the Yankees into making a rushed choice.
Interestingly, Cashman was asked if this situation was like a game of "chicken" between Cole’s camp and the Yankees. He disagreed, saying it was simply about constructive conversations taking place after the opt-out rather than before. Cashman emphasized that it’s easier to find common ground when you’re actively discussing options, rather than reacting to an opt-out decision as if it’s set in stone. "I don’t look at it as anything other than more conversations," he remarked, highlighting the importance of open dialogue over hard-and-fast contract clauses.
For Yankees fans, this agreement comes as a huge relief. Cole has proven to be a true anchor for the team since joining in 2020, not only fulfilling a childhood dream of donning the Yankees’ pinstripes but also becoming one of the most reliable pitchers in the league. Back in 2020, Cole joined New York on what was then the largest contract ever for a pitcher: nine years, $324 million. Over the last four seasons, he’s been everything the Yankees hoped for, from his consistency on the mound to his leadership presence in the clubhouse. In 2023, he reached new heights, delivering a 15-4 record and a stellar 2.63 ERA across 209 innings in 33 starts, earning him his first-ever Cy Young Award.
However, 2023 didn’t come without its setbacks. Cole faced some health challenges in spring training, experiencing nerve irritation and edema in his elbow. Thankfully, he avoided surgery and worked through a rehab program, eventually making his season debut on June 19 against the Orioles. Though he was initially limited in pitch count, Cole gradually ramped up, logging impressive performances. By the end of the season, Cole had thrown at least six innings in eight of his 17 starts, maintaining a respectable 3.41 ERA across 95 innings. While he did have tough games against teams like the Red Sox and the Mets, his overall performance was solid, and he displayed his dominance in a memorable nine-inning outing against the Athletics in September.
Cole’s postseason contributions were equally notable. In five playoff starts, he posted a strong 2.17 ERA across 29 innings. His standout performance came in the American League Division Series, where he held the Royals to a single run over seven innings, helping the Yankees clinch the series in Game 4. While the Yankees didn’t secure a World Series victory, Cole remained a critical piece of their postseason efforts, showcasing his resilience and competitiveness on the biggest stage.
Unfortunately, Cole’s final game of the season ended on a sour note for the Yankees. In a matchup against the Dodgers, a series of defensive missteps, including one where Cole failed to cover first base on a routine grounder, allowed the Dodgers to rally and eventually win the game. Despite Cole’s impressive pitching through four hitless innings, the Yankees' defensive blunders allowed the Dodgers to tie the game with five unearned runs. The game ultimately marked a painful exit for the Yankees, but Cole’s efforts were far from forgotten.
Looking back at his journey, Cole has come a long way since being drafted first overall by the Pittsburgh Pirates in 2011. After a solid but not stellar start with Pittsburgh, he transformed into a true ace when traded to the Houston Astros in 2018. His two seasons in Houston saw him emerge as one of the league’s top pitchers, logging back-to-back 200-plus-inning seasons with a 2.68 ERA. When he hit free agency, he was one of the most sought-after players, and the Yankees’ hefty nine-year contract offer was the ultimate show of faith in his talent.
Cashman noted that Cole’s decision to remain with the Yankees was about more than just the money. "I think he's happy where he's at," Cashman said, adding that Cole feels a genuine connection to the Yankees organization, his teammates, and the fans. For Cole, the allure of New York and the potential to win with the Yankees is powerful. "Sometimes the grass isn't always greener," Cashman remarked, alluding to the mutual understanding that keeping Cole as their ace was the best outcome for both sides.
So, as Yankees fans look ahead to the next season, they can rest assured that their ace will be back on the mound, ready to lead the rotation once more. While the four-year commitment locks in Cole’s presence, Cashman didn’t rule out the possibility of future discussions about extending the contract. For now, though, the focus shifts to making the most of the years they have with Cole and aiming for that elusive World Series title.
In a sport where loyalty and long-term commitments are increasingly rare, the Yankees and Cole have managed to find a middle ground that allows them to keep working toward their shared goals. With his dedication and impressive skill set, Gerrit Cole remains an invaluable asset for the Yankees, and fans can look forward to many more memorable moments as he continues to pursue greatness in pinstripes.
Login