The Green Bay Packers have never been shy about expressing their frustration over Jaire Alexander’s ongoing injury issues over the past four seasons. In fact, general manager Brian Gutekunst didn’t hold back in his season-ending press conference in mid-January, calling the situation “really, really frustrating.” When a player of Alexander’s caliber struggles to stay on the field consistently, it’s bound to raise concerns. But is the frustration only about the injuries themselves, or is there something deeper going on behind the scenes—perhaps an issue with playing through injuries?
A Growing Disconnect?
According to Rob Demovsky of ESPN, multiple team sources have privately voiced their frustration with Alexander’s inability to stay healthy and, more importantly, his reluctance to play through injuries. The Packers have openly discussed their displeasure with his frequent absences, but the real question is whether they believe he could be doing more to stay on the field.
It’s a tough situation for both sides. Injuries are an unfortunate reality of the game, and no player wants to be sidelined. At the same time, teams rely on their star players to push through adversity, especially when they are being paid at an elite level. Alexander, one of the highest-paid cornerbacks in the league, has missed significant time due to injuries, leading to mounting frustration within the organization.
The Injury Timeline
The struggles began in 2021 when Alexander suffered a shoulder injury that kept him out for 13 consecutive games. Since then, he has dealt with a series of nagging issues, including groin, back, shoulder, and knee injuries. His most recent setback—a knee injury suffered in Week 8 of the 2023 season—proved to be especially problematic. After initially trying to return following the Packers' bye week, Alexander aggravated the injury and ultimately missed the rest of the season, despite practicing sporadically in the final two months.
The Demands of the Position
It’s important to recognize that Alexander’s role as a cornerback makes it particularly challenging to play through injuries. Unlike quarterbacks, who can sometimes adjust their mechanics or playing style to compensate for minor injuries, cornerbacks must be at their absolute best in terms of speed, agility, and confidence. Covering elite NFL wide receivers requires razor-sharp movements and split-second reactions, and any physical limitation can spell disaster.
Moreover, cornerbacks aren’t just responsible for coverage—they also need to be willing tacklers. Taking down bigger, stronger offensive players is no small task, and even a slight hesitation due to injury can lead to costly mistakes. Confidence plays a massive role in the position, and fighting through injury can sap that confidence in an instant. Just ask Jordan Love—if a player isn’t fully sure their body will hold up, it affects every aspect of their game.
Playing Through Pain: A Tough Balancing Act
This raises a bigger debate: when should a player push through an injury, and when is it smarter to sit out? Some players are known for their toughness, battling through injuries and still delivering at a high level. Others, for better or worse, prioritize their long-term health and only play when they feel 100% ready. Neither approach is necessarily wrong, but in a results-driven league, teams often expect their stars to show up when it matters most.
For Alexander, this situation puts him in a difficult spot. If he pushes too hard and worsens an injury, he risks long-term damage. But if he plays it too safe, he faces scrutiny from coaches, teammates, and fans. It’s a fine line, and the Packers’ growing frustration suggests they may believe he’s leaning too much toward caution.
What’s Next for Alexander and the Packers?
With two years left on his contract, Alexander’s future with the Packers is now a key offseason storyline. The team must decide if they can rely on him to stay healthy and be a consistent contributor in 2025 and beyond. If doubts continue to linger, they may have to consider their options—whether that means restructuring his deal, seeking a trade, or simply preparing for life without their star cornerback.
This situation highlights the tough realities of the NFL. On paper, Alexander remains one of the most talented defensive backs in the league. But talent alone isn’t enough—availability is just as crucial. As the Packers evaluate their roster and make offseason decisions, Alexander’s ability (or willingness) to play through injuries will undoubtedly be a major factor in shaping the team’s plans.
Final Thoughts
At the end of the day, both Alexander and the Packers are frustrated for good reason. Alexander wants to be on the field, making plays and proving why he’s one of the best in the game. The Packers, on the other hand, need their top cornerback available to help them win games. Whether this situation leads to a resolution or further tension remains to be seen, but one thing is clear—this offseason will be a defining moment in Alexander’s career and his future in Green Bay.
Login