Nick Cross 2.0? Colts Safety Thriving Under New Defensive Scheme in 2025
If there's one name that’s been buzzing around the Indianapolis Colts’ training camp this summer, it’s Nick Cross—and for all the right reasons. After a 2024 season that saw him blossom into one of the league’s top tacklers, the 23-year-old safety is now adapting to a revamped Colts defense led by the experienced Lou Anarumo. And guess what? He’s thriving.
Let’s be real—Cross's journey hasn’t exactly been smooth sailing. In fact, his first two seasons in the league were filled with ups and downs, mostly spent on the sidelines or rotating in on specific packages. But when the opportunity came knocking last summer, Cross not only answered—he kicked the door down.
That breakout season in 2024? It wasn’t just good. It was legit elite.
146 tackles.
Top 10 in the NFL.
Three interceptions.
Coverage that locked guys down to under 10 yards a catch.
And a physical presence in the run game that kept backs in check at the second level.
Yeah, Cross didn’t just show up—he showed out.
🧠 A Different Defensive Beast with Lou Anarumo
Now, as Cross prepares for Year 4, there’s a new architect pulling the strings on defense—Lou Anarumo, who’s known for his complex disguises, hybrid coverages, and the kind of strategic wizardry that keeps quarterbacks guessing. This isn’t your vanilla "cover-2 and pray" defense. Anarumo brings layers, and for a safety like Cross, that means more responsibility and even more chances to shine.
During a recent training camp session, Anarumo didn’t hold back in his praise for the rising star:
"I'm happy and pleased with where he's at," Anarumo told Horseshoe Huddle. "It's a different deal for him. I think he's built on the foundation he laid in the spring and really kind of just hit the ground running when we got back. He’s done some good things out here.”
It’s that foundation—those offseason reps and the mental reps—that Anarumo is banking on to transform Cross from just a solid starter to a centerpiece of the secondary.
🔍 Let’s Talk Scheme Fit
In Anarumo’s system, there’s no room for one-trick ponies. The safeties have to be versatile, quick thinkers who can switch roles in a flash. One snap, you’re dropping deep in a two-high shell. The next? You're crashing down to take on a tight end in man coverage or disguising a blitz from the slot.
This is where Cross’s growth has been most noticeable.
He’s no longer just the downhill thumper with raw athleticism. In this new-look Colts defense, Cross has shown flashes of elite football IQ, recognizing formations, adjusting coverage alignments, and even calling out pre-snap tendencies.
And with Cam Bynum joining the team in free agency, the Colts now have a true partner to allow Cross to play more freely in his natural strong safety role. Bynum brings experience and flexibility—exactly what this system demands.
📈 From Flash to Fixture
The real turning point came last summer, when Cross flat-out dominated the competition in camp and seized the starting job. After two years of inconsistent usage, he became a fixture in the Colts’ secondary. He didn't just fill a spot—he owned it.
What’s crazy is that Cross isn’t resting on his success. He’s still attacking every practice like he has something to prove—and maybe he does. After all, 2024 proved he belongs. But 2025? That’s about proving he can be elite—every snap, every game.
💥 The Numbers Don’t Lie
Here’s where things get juicy. According to Pro Football Focus, Cross’s impact went way beyond just the eye test. In 2024:
-
He allowed fewer than 10.0 yards per reception in coverage.
-
He logged three picks, a career high.
-
He broke up two crucial passes that changed the momentum in big games.
-
He tackled like a linebacker but moved like a cornerback.
Add all that up, and you've got a safety that not only hits hard but plays smart—and that’s a nightmare for opposing offenses.
🎯 What’s Next?
Looking ahead to the regular season, it’s clear that Cross is more than just a starter—he's a building block for Anarumo's vision of an aggressive, flexible, and unpredictable defense. Whether it’s dropping back in cover-3, pressing in man, or patrolling the box, Cross will be asked to wear multiple hats.
And let’s not forget: the AFC South is loaded with young quarterback talent and explosive offenses. Guys like Trevor Lawrence, C.J. Stroud, and Will Levis are going to test this defense in every way possible. But with Cross anchoring the back end, the Colts aren’t just reacting—they’re attacking.
🎤 Final Thoughts: Nick Cross is Just Getting Started
The rise of Nick Cross is the kind of story every franchise hopes for—a mid-round pick who battles through early struggles, finds his groove, and then levels up under a new scheme. That’s the kind of growth you can’t coach; it comes from within.
And if training camp is any indication, Cross is only getting faster, smarter, and more confident.
He’s not just a strong safety anymore. He’s a problem—for running backs, for quarterbacks, and for offensive coordinators across the NFL.
So, Colts fans, buckle up.
Nick Cross 2.0 is here—and this version might just take the league by storm.
Login