Orioles Might Wave the White Flag: Could Ryan O’Hearn Be the First to Go?
The Baltimore Orioles came into this season riding a high. With a loaded roster of promising young talent and sky-high expectations, many fans were thinking postseason — maybe even a deep run. But baseball has a brutal way of humbling even the most hyped squads. And in Baltimore's case, it was the pitching staff that cracked the foundation. From early bullpen collapses to starters struggling to get out of the fourth inning, things unraveled quickly — and publicly.
Now, here we are at midseason, and the Orioles are sitting at a crossroads. Do they double down and try to patch things up? Or do they face the music and shift into seller mode before the trade deadline hits? If the latest buzz from insiders like Jim Bowden of The Athletic is any indicator, it seems like Baltimore's front office might already be leaning toward the latter.
"If the Orioles become sellers," Bowden shared, "O’Hearn could end up being the trade deadline headliner for Baltimore."
And that makes sense. While the Orioles’ young core — guys like Adley Rutschman and Gunnar Henderson — is still the heartbeat of the team’s future, there are a few veterans whose contracts are expiring and whose contributions, while solid, may be better cashed in now than later.
One of those veterans? Ryan O’Hearn — a name that might not make national headlines every day, but definitely should be on any contender’s radar come late July.
O’Hearn’s 2025 Season: Quietly Productive, Versatile, and Affordable
Let’s take a second to appreciate what O’Hearn is doing this year. Through 244 at-bats, he’s slashing an impressive .295/.383/.473 with 11 home runs and 30 RBIs. That kind of line doesn’t just pop up out of nowhere. He's been consistent, productive, and arguably one of the brighter spots in an otherwise frustrating season for Baltimore.
Not only is he hitting well, but his value gets a bump from his versatility. While he’s most comfortable at designated hitter, O’Hearn can also play first base and even dabble in left field. That kind of flexibility could be gold for a playoff contender needing a lefty bat with some pop.
Oh — and the cherry on top? He’s only making $8 million this year. That’s basically a bargain for a bat like his, especially given how inflated the market can get closer to deadline day. Add in that he's a soon-to-be free agent, and you have the perfect rental piece for a club trying to boost its offense without blowing up the payroll.
The Trade Market: Who’s Lurking Around the Corner?
Naturally, the trade rumor mill is heating up, and a few suitors have already been whispered around the league.
The Cincinnati Reds have been repeatedly linked to left-handed hitters and are always on the lookout for impact bats who won’t break the bank. O’Hearn fits that mold almost too perfectly. Cincinnati has young talent that they’d be willing to part with — especially if it means adding a lefty bat to deepen their lineup.
Another interesting fit? The Boston Red Sox. Boston’s in a strange spot — they’ve been competitive but inconsistent, and one of their biggest gaps is at first base. A guy like O’Hearn could plug that hole while providing some veteran presence. But here’s the catch: intra-division trades are always tricky. Would the Orioles really send a slugger like O’Hearn to a direct rival in the AL East? Seems unlikely, but not impossible if the return is strong enough.
Why Selling Makes Sense for Baltimore
Let’s be honest: it sucks to wave the white flag halfway through a season. But for the Orioles, selling isn’t giving up — it’s strategic repositioning. Their window isn’t closing — it's just opening. Rutschman, Henderson, Colton Cowser, Jackson Holliday — this team has one of the deepest pipelines in MLB. Moving O’Hearn now doesn’t mean tearing things down. It means maximizing value while you still can.
And let’s not forget — if O’Hearn walks at the end of the year, the Orioles get nothing. Trading him before the deadline could land them a solid bullpen arm, a fringe starter, or even a young prospect to stash in the minors. These are the kinds of savvy moves that good organizations make when they’re thinking long-term.
Don't Expect a Massive Bidding War
One thing to keep in mind here: while O’Hearn is having a strong year, he’s still viewed mostly as a DH-first player. That means his trade value will be somewhat limited. The market for designated hitters isn’t as hot as it is for two-way players. Some GMs see DHs as luxury pieces — the kind you add when everything else is clicking. That could dampen the return Baltimore gets, but it doesn’t eliminate the value entirely.
Still, his ability to stand at first base or trot out to left field in a pinch gives him enough defensive flexibility to broaden his market appeal. He may not be a Gold Glove finalist, but he’s competent enough to make him more than just a bat-for-hire.
What Happens Next?
The next few weeks will be critical. If the Orioles go on a sudden hot streak and the pitching miraculously finds its groove, the front office might hit pause on any sell-off plans. But if the slide continues — especially in such a competitive AL East — you can bet O’Hearn’s name will be one of the first tossed around in serious trade talks.
And here’s the wild card: what if someone overpays? It happens all the time near the deadline. A contender loses a key bat to injury, panics, and suddenly Ryan O’Hearn looks like the best available option. That’s when the Orioles really stand to cash in.
Final Thought: Play Smart, Not Sentimental
Orioles fans have been through a lot — years of rebuilding, losing seasons, watching stars leave town. So it's totally fair if some people are attached to O’Hearn and would rather see the team hold on to its productive veterans. But this move — if it happens — isn’t about sentiment. It’s about strategy.
Ryan O’Hearn has been a quiet force in 2025. And while he’s earned respect in Baltimore, it might be time for him to take his bat — and value — somewhere new, while the Orioles continue their quest to build something sustainable for the long haul.
Login