The Monday sun rose brightly over the city, casting a clear light on the Philadelphia Phillies' downtown skyline as viewed from their winter meetings suite. With the offseason in full swing, the Phillies' brass was focused not only on the spectacular cityscape but also on their roster's outlook for the upcoming season. The question loomed: What’s the best way to respond when your NL East rival snags Juan Soto in a jaw-dropping deal?
If you're the Phillies, maybe the answer starts with some perspective. Last season, they racked up an impressive 95 wins. Sure, Soto is now a Met—rolling in money with a record-setting contract—but that doesn’t mean the Phillies are sitting idly by. President of Baseball Operations Dave Dombrowski summed it up: “We were a top-five offense in baseball in a lot of areas. It didn’t look like it in the last four games of the playoffs, but we have a good offensive team as it is.”
A Balanced Approach: No Need for Hasty Moves
Dombrowski’s approach is one of cautious optimism. “You’re always looking to get better,” he explained, “but if you told me we went in with the same players we have right now, I still think we have a good offensive club. Because we’re not going to force things to happen to just get them done.” These are measured words, especially as they come two months before spring training.
But make no mistake, the Phillies aren’t standing pat. This is a team as all-in as ever, with owner John Middleton laser-focused on reclaiming the elusive World Series trophy. If that means shaking up the roster, so be it. The possibility of trading Alec Bohm—a cornerstone of the team’s offense—has been floated by rival evaluators. Bohm, after all, isn’t easily replaced. He’s posted back-to-back 97-RBI seasons, ranks high in productivity with runners in scoring position, and earned an All-Star start just five months ago.
Still, as enticing as Bohm's trade value might seem, the Phillies must tread carefully. “If we’re going to make a move, you don’t want to get worse because you’re making a deal,” Dombrowski emphasized. “You want to at least be equal if you’re changing faces.”
The Soto Effect: Kickstarting the Offseason
The shockwaves of Soto’s colossal 15-year, $765 million deal with the Mets are rippling through baseball. The Phillies, however, were never serious players for the superstar slugger. They didn’t meet with Soto or even make an offer. As Dombrowski noted, “We had enough of a pulse to know what was taking place.” Instead, they let the Mets, Yankees, Red Sox, Blue Jays, and Dodgers battle it out.
Still, the Soto signing has jumpstarted free agency. Agents are now more willing to engage in conversations, and the Phillies wasted no time reeling in a key addition. They signed former Blue Jays closer Jordan Romano to a one-year deal worth $8.5 million. While not as headline-grabbing as Soto’s contract, it’s a savvy move that bolsters the bullpen and addresses a pressing need.
Trade Winds and the Astros Connection
If free agency is heating up, the trade market isn’t far behind. With the Phillies’ payroll brushing against the $281 million luxury tax threshold, significant roster changes are more likely to come via trades. One intriguing trade partner to watch? The Houston Astros.
The Astros are juggling their own financial considerations as they aim to re-sign Alex Bregman, a cornerstone of their 2017 and 2022 World Series-winning teams. If they need to free up payroll space, players like Framber Valdez or Kyle Tucker might become available. Tucker, in particular, would be a dream fit for the Phillies, bringing an average of 28 homers and an .888 OPS over the last four seasons.
“We’ll listen on anybody,” Astros GM Dana Brown said, hinting at the possibility of moves involving Tucker. It’s a tantalizing prospect for Phillies fans hungry for change.
Staying the Course vs. Shaking Things Up
Despite the buzz around trades and free agency, the Phillies face a tricky balancing act. On one hand, their 2023 season ended with the second-best record in the National League and a commanding six-game division lead over the Mets and Braves. On the other hand, the fan base is clamoring for moves to ensure they stay ahead of NL East rivals bolstered by Soto and a healthy Ronald Acuña Jr. in Atlanta.
“Everybody has some warts in their game,” Dombrowski pointed out. “People point to our warts more than they point to the positive because we lost in the playoffs. But there’s a lot of good things about our offense and a lot of good players.”
Looking Ahead
As the Phillies navigate the offseason, their strategy appears rooted in pragmatism and ambition. They’re not rushing to overhaul a roster that brought significant success last year, but they’re also not content to rest on their laurels. Whether it’s through trades, targeted free-agent signings, or internal development, the goal remains clear: to build a team capable of capturing the ultimate prize.
For now, the view from the winter meetings suite is as clear as the December sky. The Phillies know their strengths, their weaknesses, and the stakes. As fans await the next move, one thing is certain: this team isn’t afraid to take bold steps when it matters most.
Login