Panama's Stunning Upset Forces USMNT to Rethink Everything
Sometimes, sports deliver moments that leave an entire fanbase speechless. That’s exactly what happened when Panama pulled off a shocker, knocking the United States men’s national team (USMNT) out of the CONCACAF Nations League final. For the first time in the competition’s short history, the Americans won’t be hoisting the trophy, and now they’ll have to settle for a third-place battle against either Mexico or Canada. But beyond the scoreboard, this match raised some serious questions about the state of Mauricio Pochettino’s squad, just 16 months away from a home-soil World Cup.
A Game of Missed Opportunities and Unanswered Questions
On paper, the USMNT had all the tools to take care of business. They dominated possession with 66% of the ball, outshot Panama 12-3, and controlled the tempo for large stretches. However, the final touch was nowhere to be found. With key players like Antonee Robinson, Folarin Balogun, Sergiño Dest, and Ricardo Pepi sidelined, the team lacked cutting-edge finishing and attacking creativity. Even secondary contributors such as Malik Tillman, Johnny Cardoso, and Haji Wright were absent, further depleting Pochettino’s options.
And then there’s the lingering issue of goalkeeping. Matt Turner, who has been reliable in the past, couldn’t come up with a save on Panama’s lone shot on target. In high-stakes elimination matches, these small moments define the outcome, and this one didn’t fall in the USMNT’s favor. The defensive lapses, combined with an inability to capitalize on chances, left fans frustrated and demanding answers.
Pulisic and McKennie Struggle Under Pressure
When Christian Pulisic is at his best, the USMNT is a different beast. But when he’s neutralized—as he was for much of this match—the team struggles to find alternative attacking solutions. Panama’s defense effectively contained him with man-marking, double teams, and some well-timed physical challenges. The first half saw the U.S. dominate possession but fail to deliver meaningful final balls.
Timothy Weah injected energy into the second half, sparking some life in the attack, but Pulisic still couldn’t find his rhythm. His set-piece deliveries lacked precision, and his usual flair in open play was missing. Weston McKennie, another key figure, also had an uncharacteristically quiet night, struggling to impose himself in midfield. Without their stars clicking, the USMNT lacked the creative spark to unlock Panama’s disciplined backline.
Who Wants the Center Forward Role?
One of the biggest takeaways from this match was the ongoing uncertainty surrounding the striker position. The U.S. has long struggled to develop elite center-forwards, and that void was glaring once again. With Balogun and Pepi unavailable, Pochettino handed the start to Josh Sargent. The Norwich City striker had his moments—he found the back of the net, only to see the goal ruled out due to a marginal offside call against Weah. Later, he came inches away from scoring when a deflected shot bounced off the post.
Patrick Agyemang also had a promising cameo off the bench, nearly overpowering Panama’s defense with raw physicality before an unfortunate miscue saw him mishit a golden opportunity. While these moments showed flashes of potential, the reality remains that the USMNT is still searching for a reliable, go-to finisher in high-pressure situations.
A Moment for the Ages – Panama’s Unforgettable Celebration
If you’re a neutral, this game delivered a scene straight out of a Hollywood script. When José Fajardo netted Panama’s stoppage-time winner, the celebrations were nothing short of legendary. The goal sent shockwaves through the stadium and secured a historic moment for Los Canaleros.
Perhaps the most iconic part of the celebration came when Andrés Andrade leapt into the arms of CBS analyst and Arsenal legend Thierry Henry. In a surreal moment, Andrade excitedly told Henry, “You are my idol,” not once, but twice, in Spanish. It was pure emotion, the kind of raw, unfiltered joy that makes soccer so special. As Panama’s entire squad swarmed Henry in celebration, the gravity of the upset truly set in.
Where Does the USMNT Go From Here?
With the Nations League trophy now out of reach, the USMNT must regroup quickly. A third-place game against either Mexico or Canada is still on the horizon, but the bigger picture is what truly matters. This match exposed weaknesses that need addressing before the 2026 World Cup.
-
Goalkeeper Uncertainty – Is Matt Turner still the undisputed No. 1, or should Pochettino explore other options?
-
Center Forward Dilemma – Who will step up and claim the striker position?
-
Pulisic Dependency – How can the U.S. create more attacking depth so they don’t rely too heavily on their star player?
-
Tactical Adjustments – Possession is great, but if it doesn’t translate into goals, what needs to change?
The road ahead isn’t smooth, but this loss could serve as a wake-up call. With the World Cup inching closer, Pochettino and his squad must take these lessons to heart and ensure they don’t find themselves in a similar position when the stakes are even higher.
Login