Yankees Shake Up Their Roster: Could Paul Goldschmidt Be the Next Big Move?
The New York Yankees have been making waves this offseason, but not everything has gone according to plan. After missing out on re-signing star outfielder Juan Soto, fans were left wondering how general manager Brian Cashman would recover from the disappointment. Spoiler alert: he’s been busy. With a string of bold moves, the Yankees are clearly setting their sights on reshaping their roster for the better. But could Paul Goldschmidt be the next big piece in their puzzle? Let’s dive into the whirlwind of action and speculation surrounding the Bronx Bombers.
A Flurry of Big Moves
Cashman wasted no time after Soto’s departure. The Yankees have already locked in starting pitcher Max Fried with a blockbuster $218 million deal. Known for his dominance on the mound, Fried is expected to anchor the Yankees’ rotation for years to come. But that’s not all. The team also swung trades for closer Devin Williams and versatile outfielder/first baseman Cody Bellinger, signaling their determination to build a squad that can compete at the highest level.
Bellinger’s arrival is particularly exciting for Yankees fans. The former 2019 National League MVP, known for his power and defensive versatility, brings a dynamic element to the team. Initial reports suggest that Bellinger might take over in center field, with Aaron Judge potentially shifting back to his natural position in right field. However, Bellinger’s exact role is still up in the air, leaving room for strategic adjustments as the season approaches.
The First Base Conundrum
While the Yankees have strengthened their pitching and outfield, their infield remains a work in progress—especially at first base. The position has been a glaring weakness for New York, with the team posting a dismal -1.1 WAR at first base in 2024, according to FanGraphs. For a franchise with championship aspirations, that kind of production simply won’t cut it.
Enter the rumors. New York has been linked to top-tier free agents like Pete Alonso and Christian Walker, both of whom would bring significant upgrades. However, the Yankees might be eyeing a more economical and short-term solution: Paul Goldschmidt.
Goldschmidt, the 2022 National League MVP Award winner, could be the perfect fit for the Yankees' needs. With his experience and leadership, he offers more than just stats—he brings a veteran presence to a clubhouse hungry for success. MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand even floated Goldschmidt’s name as a viable option for New York after the Bellinger trade.
Why Goldschmidt Makes Sense
Goldschmidt’s resume speaks for itself. Though his 2024 season wasn’t his best, he still managed a respectable .716 OPS with 22 home runs and 65 RBIs over 654 plate appearances. At 37 years old, he may not be in his prime, but his consistent track record suggests he still has plenty to offer.
Perhaps the most intriguing aspect of targeting Goldschmidt is his projected cost. According to Spotrac, he’s expected to command a modest one-year, $12.3 million contract. For a team already absorbing Bellinger’s $27.5 million salary (with the Cubs covering $2.5 million), a short-term deal for Goldschmidt could provide the Yankees with flexibility while addressing their first base woes.
How Would Goldschmidt Fit In?
If the Yankees bring in Goldschmidt, he would likely slot in as their everyday first baseman, providing stability and power to a position that’s been a revolving door of mediocrity. His presence would also take some pressure off other parts of the lineup, allowing stars like Aaron Judge and Cody Bellinger to focus on their roles without worrying about carrying the offense alone.
Moreover, Goldschmidt’s veteran experience could prove invaluable in high-pressure moments. He’s been through the grind of MLB postseasons, and his leadership could help guide younger players on the roster. For a Yankees team aiming to return to its championship pedigree, that kind of intangible value can’t be overstated.
The Alternatives
Of course, Goldschmidt isn’t the only option on the table. The Yankees have reportedly shown interest in bigger names like Pete Alonso, whose power-hitting prowess could electrify the Bronx. However, Alonso’s market value and long-term contract demands might make him a less attractive option for a team already investing heavily in other areas.
Similarly, Christian Walker is another name to watch. Known for his solid defense and offensive production, Walker would bring a well-rounded skill set to first base. But, like Alonso, his price tag might push the Yankees to consider more cost-effective solutions.
Other potential targets include Carlos Santana, a switch-hitting veteran with a knack for getting on base. While Santana might not bring the same star power as Goldschmidt, his consistent approach at the plate could be a valuable asset in the Yankees’ lineup.
What’s Next for the Yankees?
With spring training just around the corner, the Yankees still have time to make additional moves. Whether they go all-in on a blockbuster signing or opt for a more measured approach, one thing is clear: Brian Cashman is leaving no stone unturned in his quest to build a championship-caliber team.
The addition of Max Fried, Devin Williams, and Cody Bellinger has already reshaped the Yankees’ roster. But plugging the hole at first base remains a top priority. If Goldschmidt ends up in pinstripes, he could be the final piece that pushes the Bombers back into contention.
Final Thoughts
Yankees fans have plenty to be excited about as the offseason unfolds. While missing out on Juan Soto was a tough pill to swallow, the team’s recent moves suggest they’re far from done. With Paul Goldschmidt potentially on the horizon, the Bronx Bombers might just be assembling a roster capable of making serious noise in 2025.
Will Cashman pull the trigger on another bold move? Only time will tell, but one thing is for certain: the Yankees are all-in on chasing their next World Series title. And for fans in the Bronx, that’s music to their ears.
Login