Zack Wheeler’s journey from a rookie playoff pitcher to one of the Phillies’ most dependable postseason starters is nothing short of remarkable. It's a tale filled with unexpected turns, personal redemption, and the kind of poise under pressure that sets him apart. When the Phillies finally broke their 11-year playoff drought in 2022, Wheeler was handed the ball for Game 1 of the National League wild-card series against the Cardinals. It was his debut on the biggest stage of baseball, a moment that would kick off his growing legacy as one of the sport's top playoff performers.
Wheeler’s playoff journey, however, didn’t start as some might expect. Back in 2015, when he was with the New York Mets, the team made a run to the World Series. But Wheeler wasn’t a part of that magical ride. He was rehabbing from Tommy John elbow surgery, a process that had him watching from the sidelines. To add insult to injury, the Mets told him he'd have to purchase his own playoff tickets. Instead, Wheeler chose to stay home and watch from his couch. Talk about a tough pill to swallow, especially for a player with dreams of pitching under the bright lights of October.
Fast forward to today, and Zack Wheeler is a completely different version of himself—a battle-tested playoff pitcher preparing for yet another Game 1. This time, it’s not against the Cardinals, but in an epic first-ever postseason matchup between the Phillies and the Mets, the very team that once snubbed him. Now with 63⅓ postseason innings to his name, Wheeler is no longer the novice he was in 2022. He’s a seasoned veteran, ready to take the mound with a clear sense of purpose. In fact, if you think about it, who better to lead the Phillies into battle than the guy the Mets let go?
The Calm Before the Storm
What sets Wheeler apart isn’t just his blistering fastball or his ability to go deep into games—it’s his demeanor. Phillies manager Rob Thomson has said that Wheeler’s calmness and poise give him a unique edge, especially in the high-stakes environment of the playoffs. While the pressure of October baseball gets to many pitchers, Wheeler’s unflappable presence is a stabilizing force for his teammates.
“You always get nerves,” Wheeler admits. “But once you get out there, they kind of settle down a little bit. You just do your normal job and pitch, and try to do the best you can.” It’s an interesting statement from a guy who, by all accounts, seems immune to pressure. But maybe that’s what makes Wheeler so effective: he acknowledges the nerves but doesn’t let them consume him. Instead, he harnesses them, channeling that energy into every pitch.
Catcher J.T. Realmuto, who has been behind the plate for each of Wheeler’s postseason appearances since 2022, paints a vivid picture of Wheeler’s relaxed nature. “Talking to him in meetings before every single game, sometimes it looks like he’s actually about to fall asleep, and this is like an hour before the game,” Realmuto said with a chuckle. “He’s just that calm. It’s almost like he’s meditating. He’s just laying there, listening and focusing.”
Built for October
Wheeler’s ability to stay calm under pressure isn’t just anecdotal—it shows in the numbers. With a career postseason ERA of 2.42, Wheeler ranks fifth all-time among qualified pitchers in playoff history. That’s no small feat, and it speaks volumes about his ability to elevate his game when the stakes are highest. In the chaotic, high-octane atmosphere of playoff baseball, Wheeler’s calm is his superpower.
“He doesn’t get rattled,” manager Rob Thomson says. “That’s what makes him built for this time of year.” Thomson isn’t the only one who’s noticed. Wheeler’s quiet intensity has become something of a legend within the Phillies clubhouse. He’s the guy they all count on when the pressure mounts, the one who sets the tone for the rest of the team.
And it’s not just about poise—Wheeler has the stuff to back it up. His fastball can hit the upper 90s, and he mixes in a deadly slider and curveball, keeping hitters off-balance. It’s that combination of overpowering stuff and cool-headed execution that makes him so dangerous in the postseason.
Facing Familiar Foes: The Mets
The upcoming series against the Mets adds an extra layer of intrigue to Wheeler’s playoff journey. It’s the first time in the Phillies’ 141-year history that they’ll face their division rival in the postseason. For Wheeler, who spent the early part of his career with the Mets, it’s a reunion of sorts—but don’t expect him to be overly sentimental about it.
“They know me; I know them. And it’s kind of a cat-and-mouse game at this point,” Wheeler said. “It’s pretty fresh, but at the same time, get out there, see how the game starts going, maybe we change some things up; maybe we don’t. I’m going to pitch to my strengths and how I pitch. If we need to veer from that, we will.”
Wheeler last faced the Mets on September 22, and while he posted a quality start, he was charged with the loss. But that’s in the past. October baseball is a different beast, and Wheeler has shown time and again that he thrives in these moments.
Despite his history with the Mets, Wheeler holds no grudges. “It’s always fun to face them,” he said, acknowledging that most of the personnel from his time with the team have changed. The bad blood, if there ever was any, has long since faded. Now, it’s just business.
A Dynamic Duo: Wheeler and Nola
The Phillies are banking on their ace duo—Wheeler and Aaron Nola—to lead them through the postseason once again. The pair has been a nightmare for opposing managers, and Phillies fans are hoping for a repeat of last year’s dominant run. Nola and Wheeler complement each other perfectly: Nola’s finesse and Wheeler’s power make for a one-two punch that’s tough to beat.
“They haunt managers in the playoffs,” Thomson said, reflecting on their impact. And while Nola brings his own brand of intensity to the mound, it’s Wheeler’s calm leadership that sets the tone.
Realmuto, who has caught both pitchers, notices a subtle difference in Wheeler during the playoffs. “I just think there’s a little more intensity in him when it comes to the postseason, and that’s saying a lot for somebody who’s clearly intense all season long,” Realmuto said. It’s almost as if Wheeler shifts into another gear when the calendar turns to October, embracing the responsibility of being the Phillies’ go-to guy in the biggest moments.
Conclusion: Wheeler's Unwavering Focus
As the Phillies prepare for their first-ever playoff matchup against the Mets, all eyes will be on Zack Wheeler. He’s come a long way from the days of watching the Mets in the World Series from his couch. Now, he’s the ace on the mound, ready to lead his team into battle. The stakes are higher, the pressure is immense, but if there’s one thing we know about Zack Wheeler, it’s that he won’t be rattled.
Wheeler’s journey is a testament to resilience, preparation, and the power of staying calm under pressure. The Phillies are counting on him once again to set the tone, and if history is any indication, Wheeler is more than up for the challenge.
Login