Breaking Down the Big Prisoner Swap: What Really Happened with Evan Gershkovich’s Release
Social media’s been buzzing nonstop since reporter Evan Gershkovich was freed from Russian captivity — and not just because of the dramatic nature of his release, but also due to the political drama swirling around it. Here’s the deal: back in May, Donald Trump claimed on his Truth Social platform that Russian President Vladimir Putin would release Gershkovich as a personal favor to him, the former president — and no one else. Fast forward to this week, and Gershkovich walked free as part of a massive 24-person prisoner swap involving Russia, Belarus, the United States, and several Western allies. So, what gives? Let’s unpack this.
The Swap That Shook the Headlines
On Thursday, the world watched as Moscow released 16 prisoners, including a mix of foreign nationals and domestic political prisoners. The Western nations, meanwhile, freed eight people — including some convicted spies and Vadim Krasikov, the man found guilty of assassinating an exiled dissident in Berlin. Among those freed from Russian custody were Gershkovich, Paul Whelan (who’s been held since 2018), Russian-American journalist Alsu Kurmasheva, and Vladimir Kara-Murza, a green card holder and noted political figure.
When the group landed at Joint Base Andrews in Maryland, they were warmly greeted by President Joe Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris. A major moment, symbolizing a diplomatic win, but also sparking heated debates back home.
Trump’s Bold Claim: “Putin Will Do It For Me”
Let’s rewind to May 23, 2024. Trump posted a confident message on Truth Social: “Evan Gershkovich, the Reporter from the Wall Street Journal, who is being held by Russia, will be released almost immediately after the Election, but definitely before I assume Office.” The post went on to say, “Vladimir Putin, President of Russia, will do that for me, but not for anyone else, and we WILL BE PAYING NOTHING!” That’s a pretty bold assertion — and one that has now drawn a lot of scrutiny.
Political Commentators Weigh In
As news of the release spread, political commentators on X (formerly Twitter) quickly jumped in. Nicholas Grossman, an international relations professor at the University of Illinois, tweeted:
“Happy to hear US political prisoners in Russia, including WSJ reporter Evan Gershkovich, will be coming home. Curious to find out what the US traded. Did Russia’s calculus change or did America meet their price? And can’t help but note Trump claimed that only he could do this.”
David Frum, a former speechwriter for President George W. Bush, offered his take, writing:
“Looks as if Putin has abruptly lost confidence that Trump will win in November. Locking in his hostage-taking payoff early.”
These sharp observations hint at the bigger political chess game behind the scenes, and raise questions about what the U.S. actually gave up in the exchange.
What About the Charges Against Gershkovich?
In March 2023, Gershkovich was detained on espionage charges in Russia — charges that both his employer, The Wall Street Journal, and the U.S. State Department called “fabricated.” Just recently, he was sentenced to 16 years in prison. His release now, after months of tension, was unexpected by many observers.
Paul Whelan’s case adds a layer of complexity, too. Held since December 2018, Whelan’s inclusion in the swap underscores the long and ongoing nature of American hostages in Russia.
Biden’s Response to Trump’s Claims
When asked about Trump’s repeated claim that he could have secured the release without any trade or concessions, President Biden didn’t hold back:
“Why didn’t he do it when he was president?”
It’s a straightforward jab that highlights the political tension around the whole affair. Biden’s administration clearly wants to draw a line between the current government’s handling of the issue and Trump’s previous rhetoric.
Trump’s Reaction Post-Swap: Skeptical and Critical
When reporters reached out to Trump’s campaign spokesperson, Steven Cheung, he directed them to a Truth Social post Trump made in response to the swap news. Trump didn’t hold back his criticism, writing:
“So when are they going to release the details of the prisoner swap with Russia? How many people do we get versus them? Are we also paying them cash? Are they giving us cash (Please withdraw that question, because I’m sure the answer is NO)? Are we releasing murderers, killers, or thugs?”
“Just curious because we never make good deals, at anything, but especially hostage swaps. Our ‘negotiators’ are always an embarrassment to us! I got back many hostages, and gave the opposing Country NOTHING—and never any cash. To do so is bad precedent for the future. That’s the way it should be, or this situation will get worse and worse. They are extorting the United States of America. They’re calling the trade ‘complex’—That’s so nobody can figure out how bad it is!”
In short, Trump painted the current swap as a “bad deal,” claiming his own record was far superior, and accusing current negotiators of weakness.
What Does This Mean for U.S.-Russia Relations?
This prisoner swap, involving dozens of people, including high-profile journalists and political prisoners, is a reminder of the tense, ongoing tug-of-war between Washington and Moscow. It’s a complex dance of diplomacy, power, and public messaging.
For Putin, the swap might be a calculated move to reset the narrative around U.S.-Russia relations ahead of the November U.S. elections. As David Frum noted, locking in a hostage exchange now might suggest Putin is hedging his bets about Trump’s chances.
For the U.S., bringing Americans like Gershkovich and Whelan home is a clear priority. Yet, the price paid — whatever it may be — remains officially undisclosed, feeding speculation and political debate.
Quick Takeaways: What You Need to Know
-
Evan Gershkovich’s release was part of a 24-person swap involving Russia, Belarus, the U.S., and other Western countries.
-
Trump claimed earlier this year that Putin would release Gershkovich as a favor to him alone — but that didn’t pan out exactly as he said.
-
Political commentators suggest Russia’s decision to free prisoners now might be tied to doubts about Trump’s election chances.
-
President Biden challenged Trump’s claims, asking why he didn’t act when he was in office.
-
Trump criticized the swap post-fact, claiming the U.S. gave up too much and calling current negotiators “an embarrassment.”
-
The details of what the U.S. traded remain undisclosed, leading to speculation about the true cost of the swap.
-
The release includes other Americans held by Russia, like Paul Whelan, and Russian political prisoners with ties to the U.S.
What’s Next?
As the political back-and-forth continues, the key focus will be on transparency. Will the U.S. reveal what exactly was traded? Will Trump press further on the issue during his campaign? And how will Russia respond to the shifting political winds as the U.S. heads into an election year?
For now, the safe return of Gershkovich and others is a bright spot amid a fraught diplomatic relationship — but the political fallout is just getting started.
Login