Germany, a central player in the European Union's Schengen Area, is set to tighten its borders starting next Monday. This move is significant because the Schengen Area is designed to ensure seamless internal borders and unrestricted travel between member states. But recent events have pushed Germany to reconsider its approach to border management, driven by political pressures and security concerns.
Why the Change?
The catalyst for Germany's decision is multifaceted. Recent developments include:
- A High-Profile Attack: A terrorist stabbing in Solingen by a 26-year-old Syrian man linked to ISIS has intensified the debate. The attack, which resulted in three deaths, heightened concerns about border security and immigration.
- Far-Right Gains: The far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party made significant strides in recent state elections, particularly in Thuringia and Saxony. This has pressured Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s coalition government to adopt a tougher stance on immigration and border controls.
What Are Germany’s New Plans?
From next Monday, Germany will implement systematic land border checks for six months on travelers arriving from neighboring Schengen countries like Belgium, France, Denmark, the Netherlands, and Luxembourg. This step marks a significant shift in Germany’s border policy, echoing similar measures introduced in late 2023 on its borders with Poland, the Czech Republic, and Switzerland. Here’s what you need to know:
- Increased Checks: The new plan includes more rigorous checks for those arriving by bus, train, or car. The details, such as the frequency and intensity of these checks, remain somewhat unclear.
- Existing Controls: Germany has already seen over 30,000 people turned away at its borders since implementing prior controls. The upcoming measures aim to further bolster these efforts.
Implications for Germany’s Neighbors
Germany's geographical and economic centrality within the EU means that changes to its border policy have broader implications:
- Traffic and Trade: Increased border checks could lead to traffic delays and disrupt cross-border trade. With around 240,000 people commuting from neighboring countries for work, the economic impact could be substantial.
- Reaction from Neighbors: Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk has criticized the decision, arguing that it’s “unacceptable” and advocating for greater involvement in securing the EU’s external borders. Similarly, Austria’s conservative Interior Minister Gerhard Karner has declared that Austria will not accept rejected asylum seekers from Germany.
Impact on Asylum Seekers
The German government’s goal is to reduce irregular migration and reject more asylum seekers. However, this raises concerns about what will happen to those turned away:
- Potential Backlog: Alberto-Horst Neidhardt from the European Policy Center predicts that the stricter controls might lead to a backlog of people stuck at the borders, with Germany refusing entry and neighboring countries declining to accept returnees. This could result in chaotic scenes at border points.
The EU's Asylum System and Broader Impact
The potential ripple effects of Germany’s new policies could influence the broader EU asylum system:
- Chain Reaction: Neidhardt warns that other EU countries, especially those with anti-immigration stances like France, the Netherlands, Poland, Hungary, and the Czech Republic, might follow suit. This could lead to a series of restrictive measures across the EU.
- Political Repercussions: Mireia Faro Sarrats of the European Council on Foreign Relations notes that this could set a precedent for other member states to cite security threats as justification for tightening their borders.
Reflecting on Germany’s Shift
Germany’s new border controls highlight a dramatic shift from its stance during the 2015 European migrant crisis when the country, under Chancellor Angela Merkel, opened its borders to hundreds of thousands of refugees. The recent policy change reflects growing security concerns and voter anxieties:
- Political Messaging: Neidhardt suggests that the increased border checks are more about signaling a response to voter concerns rather than effectively addressing security threats. Despite these measures, it’s unlikely to completely stop irregular arrivals.
In summary, Germany's decision to tighten border controls marks a significant pivot from its previous open-border policies. The implications for the Schengen Area, Germany’s neighbors, and the broader EU asylum system are profound, potentially setting off a chain reaction of stricter immigration measures across Europe. As Germany grapples with security concerns and political pressures, the new border policy represents a crucial moment in the ongoing debate over migration and border management in Europe.
Login