As the first phase of the ceasefire between Israel and Hamas in Gaza was expected to conclude, tensions have once again escalated, casting doubt on the agreement’s future. The release of the last six living Israeli hostages should have marked a significant step forward, with Israel set to free over 600 Palestinian prisoners—the largest single release yet. However, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has now indefinitely delayed this exchange, citing Hamas’ "cynical use of hostages for propaganda purposes." Hamas, in turn, accuses Israel of deliberately disrupting the ceasefire agreement.
A Fragile Path to Peace
The ceasefire, initially intended as a stepping stone toward lasting peace and Gaza’s reconstruction, has encountered repeated roadblocks. One of the first setbacks arose during an early hostage handover, where Israel raised concerns about the chaotic nature of the process, stating that the hostages’ physical safety had been put at risk. Shortly after, Hamas allegedly violated the agreement by failing to release a female civilian hostage, Arbel Yehud.
In retaliation, Israel delayed access for hundreds of thousands of Palestinians to return to northern Gaza for 48 hours. This standoff was resolved when Hamas released Yehud in an unscheduled handover before the next round of exchanges. However, Hamas soon accused Israel of failing to meet its own obligations, particularly regarding the entry of heavy machinery, tents, and caravans into Gaza. In response, Hamas threatened to withhold the next batch of hostages.
This led to strong warnings from both Netanyahu and then-US President Donald Trump, who threatened the resumption of full-scale war in Gaza if the agreed-upon releases did not proceed. As the clock ran down, Hamas ultimately relented and released the hostages as planned.
A Shocking Discovery
Just as tensions seemed to stabilize, another distressing revelation reignited anger in Israel. Hamas had returned a body that was initially believed to be that of Shiri Bibas. However, upon further examination, it was discovered that the remains did not belong to her. This discovery was particularly emotional for Israelis, as images of Bibas shielding her two young children during their abduction on October 7, 2023, became one of the most haunting symbols of the conflict.
Netanyahu denounced Hamas’ actions, calling it a "cruel and evil violation" of the agreement. In a last-minute move to salvage the ceasefire, Hamas provided another body within 24 hours, this time correctly identified as Bibas. This series of events underscored just how fragile and volatile the ceasefire process remains.
A Stalemate in the Second Phase
With the first phase nearing its end, negotiations for the next stage have stalled. Hamas has proposed releasing all remaining hostages at once—but only if Israel withdraws all its forces from Gaza and agrees to a permanent ceasefire. Israel, however, insists on Hamas’ complete disarmament, a demand Hamas has rejected outright.
Meanwhile, Netanyahu has strongly condemned the highly publicized, stage-managed hostage handovers, which Hamas has used to project strength. In Israel, opinions remain sharply divided. Hardliners on the right are urging the government to resume military operations against Hamas, while hostage families—supported by much of the Israeli public—prioritize securing the return of those still in captivity above all else.
The Future of Gaza: Unanswered Questions
Adding another layer of uncertainty, Trump's proposed vision for Gaza’s future has thrown discussions into disarray. The third phase of the ceasefire is supposed to lay the groundwork for Gaza’s reconstruction and long-term stability. However, Trump's plan suggests relocating Palestinians from Gaza, an idea that has sparked fierce opposition from Arab states.
In response, Arab nations are scrambling to draft an alternative proposal that would allow Palestinians to remain in Gaza while rebuilding efforts take place. Yet, the governance of post-war Gaza remains an unresolved sticking point. Israel, Hamas, the Palestinian Authority, and neighboring Arab nations each hold conflicting visions for the enclave’s future, further complicating an already delicate situation.
The Road Ahead: A Delicate Balancing Act
The ongoing uncertainty underscores the immense challenges mediators from Egypt, Qatar, and the US face in keeping the ceasefire on track. Even successfully concluding the first phase has proven to be a high-stakes balancing act, with each new day bringing the risk of renewed hostilities. With time running out and negotiations still stalled, the fate of the ceasefire—and by extension, the people of Gaza and Israel—hangs in the balance.
As both sides navigate this precarious situation, one thing remains clear: any hope for lasting peace will require difficult compromises, trust-building, and a commitment to a long-term solution—elements that, so far, have been in short supply.
Login