On August 9, a tragic event unfolded when a Voepass ATR-72 airliner crashed, leading to the loss of all 62 lives on board. This disaster, which has since become the deadliest commercial airliner crash of 2024, has spurred a significant investigation by Brazil’s Center for Research and Prevention of Aeronautical Accidents (Cenipa). The initial findings of Cenipa have shed some light on the factors contributing to this catastrophic event.
The preliminary report released by Cenipa on Friday reveals that the aircraft’s icing detectors were activated multiple times during the flight. Specifically, the plane's airframe icing button was engaged at least three times, suggesting that the crew was actively responding to ice formation issues. Cockpit recordings further revealed that the copilot expressed concerns about “a lot of icing,” hinting at a potentially serious problem with the aircraft's de-icing systems.
One of the critical aspects highlighted in the report is the repeated activation and deactivation of the airframe de-icing system by the pilots. This ongoing adjustment indicates that the flight crew was aware of the icing problem and was attempting to manage it using the onboard systems. Anthony Brickhouse, a prominent U.S. aviation safety expert, noted that this behavior aligns with efforts to combat airframe icing and its effects on the aircraft's performance.
However, the situation was dire. The ATR-72, which had taken off from Cascavel, located in the state of Paraná, was en route to São Paulo’s international airport when it spiraled out of control. The aircraft crashed in the town of Vinhedo, approximately 80 kilometers (50 miles) northwest of São Paulo. The dramatic descent was captured in various videos circulating on social media, showing the turboprop in a flat spin as it plummeted towards the ground without any visible forward movement.
The current investigation into the crash is expected to be thorough and could extend over a year. This extended timeline is necessary to piece together the full picture of what went wrong. Cenipa’s report, while providing a timeline of events, does not yet pinpoint the exact causes of the crash. It does, however, underscore the possibility that the de-icing system may have malfunctioned, which will require further investigation to confirm.
In-flight icing is a known hazard that can have severe repercussions on aircraft performance. According to Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) documents, ice build-up on an aircraft can disrupt the airflow over the wings, leading to degraded handling qualities. This can result in uncontrollable rolling or pitching of the aircraft, with recovery sometimes being impossible. The consequences of such icing can be catastrophic, as illustrated by this recent crash.
As the investigation progresses, experts are keenly examining whether ice accumulation played a significant role in the tragic events of August 9. The potential for ice build-up to trigger a series of uncontrollable events has been a key focus, and further analysis will be critical in understanding how this factor contributed to the crash.
This incident highlights the critical importance of robust aircraft de-icing systems and the need for effective management of in-flight icing conditions. The aviation community and the public await more detailed findings from Cenipa, hoping that these will provide clarity and lead to enhanced safety measures to prevent such tragedies in the future.
Login