Late Friday evening, the Senate was set to vote on the highly anticipated nomination of Pete Hegseth, President Donald Trump's pick for Secretary of Defense. Hegseth, accompanied by his wife and children, arrived at the Capitol roughly 30 minutes before the confirmation vote was scheduled to begin. His presence at the Capitol was notably unusual. Typically, nominees don't appear in person to witness the outcome of their votes, but Hegseth's choice to do so sparked attention, especially when he gave a casual thumbs-up in response to questions about his confidence in securing enough votes for confirmation.
While Hegseth's nomination has faced its fair share of scrutiny, particularly from a number of Senate Republicans, the general expectation is that he will likely secure the votes needed for confirmation. This would primarily come from Republicans, as his support among the GOP remains solid. However, the battle for confirmation hasn't been without its challenges. Despite the significant backing from the Republican side, there are some key senators who have raised doubts, adding an element of suspense to the final vote.
The Pressure Builds for Hegseth’s Confirmation
A closer look at Hegseth’s nomination reveals that this isn’t just another routine confirmation process. The scrutiny surrounding him has been intense, fueled by accusations ranging from sexual assault to financial mismanagement tied to two veterans' organizations. Despite these allegations, Hegseth has vigorously denied any wrongdoing. In fact, during a Senate Armed Services Committee hearing earlier in the month, he made a powerful case for himself, asserting that he had evolved as a person and was “a changed man.” In a moment of introspection, Hegseth admitted, “I am not a perfect person, but redemption is real.” This statement became a central part of his appeal to many Republicans who were initially hesitant about his candidacy.
His comments about redemption resonated with some key figures in the Senate, allowing him to regain the trust of many who had concerns about his past. A standout moment from the hearing was when Hegseth shared his vision for the Department of Defense, promising to restore a strong "warfighting ethos." He leaned into his experience with the National Guard, positioning himself as someone who could bring fresh energy and perspectives to the Pentagon.
The GOP Solidifies Their Support
Hegseth’s endorsement came from some prominent Senate Republicans, such as Mississippi Senator Roger Wicker, who chairs the Senate Armed Services Committee. Wicker was unequivocal in his praise for Hegseth, calling him someone with a “clear vision of the Pentagon.” He emphasized that Hegseth would bring the “energy and fresh ideas” needed to overhaul a Department of Defense mired in bureaucracy. According to Wicker, Hegseth’s focus on military readiness, his determination to deter conflicts, and his commitment to winning wars were qualities that would make him an effective leader.
However, the path to confirmation wasn't without bumps. On Monday, Hegseth’s nomination passed through the Senate Armed Services Committee on a party-line vote. Then, in a pivotal moment on Thursday, Hegseth’s nomination passed a critical test vote, paving the way for the final vote on Friday. While this momentous vote only required a simple majority to advance, it was a close call, with Republican votes being the only ones to carry him across the threshold. This highlighted the partisan divide that continues to shape the nomination process.
Two Key Republicans Hold Out
Despite the momentum building behind Hegseth, the nomination hit a snag on Thursday when two prominent Republicans, Senators Susan Collins and Lisa Murkowski, withheld their support. Both senators expressed deep reservations about Hegseth’s character and qualifications. Murkowski was particularly vocal, explaining that she could not in good conscience vote for someone she felt lacked the necessary qualities to lead the Department of Defense. She placed emphasis on the importance of character in the role, stating that the Secretary of Defense must serve as a model for the military’s core values and standards.
Collins, on the other hand, raised concerns over Hegseth’s previous comments about women serving in combat roles. While Hegseth had since revised his stance on the issue, Collins remained unconvinced. She recounted a candid conversation she had with Hegseth in December, where he seemed to have “evolving views.” Still, Collins wasn’t swayed and made it clear that she wasn’t entirely comfortable with his past statements. These concerns set the stage for a tense final vote, with both senators expected to cast votes against Hegseth's confirmation.
The President’s Confidence, Yet Uncertainty
President Trump has remained publicly confident about Hegseth's confirmation, even as the vote approached. “You’ll never know what’s going to happen,” he remarked, acknowledging the unpredictable nature of Senate votes. Trump's confidence is not without reason, as Hegseth’s nomination has received considerable backing from many in the GOP. Yet, with the final vote approaching, there remained some uncertainty, particularly regarding the votes of key Republicans.
Senators like Mitch McConnell of Kentucky and Thom Tillis of North Carolina were closely watched, as their votes could be pivotal in determining the outcome. While McConnell ultimately cast a vote in favor of advancing Hegseth’s nomination, there was still a question mark hanging over his final vote on Friday. In fact, Trump himself questioned whether McConnell might flip and vote against Hegseth when the full Senate casts their votes.
Tillis, for his part, expressed a more cautious stance. He acknowledged that there were new allegations against Hegseth, notably a troubling affidavit from Hegseth’s former sister-in-law, Danielle Hegseth. In the affidavit, she claimed that Pete’s ex-wife Samantha had once hidden in a closet to escape a volatile encounter with him. The affidavit also alleged episodes of binge drinking by Hegseth. Although an attorney for Hegseth denied these claims, and his ex-wife rejected the abuse allegations, Tillis seemed to be proceeding with caution.
Tillis confirmed that he was still in the process of evaluating the new allegations and conducting his due diligence. He emphasized that he was looking for credible, firsthand accounts before making a final decision. “It all goes back to the same thing – first-hand, eye-witness, corroborated account,” he remarked. This level of scrutiny underlined the complexity of the confirmation process, as senators weighed past allegations against Hegseth’s potential as a leader of the Department of Defense.
The Nail-Biting Final Vote
At the end of the day, Hegseth can afford to lose the support of three Republicans. If one more Republican switches their vote, Hegseth would need a tiebreaker vote from Vice President J.D. Vance to secure confirmation. The suspense surrounding the final tally added a layer of drama to the confirmation process, with all eyes on the Republican senators who remained on the fence. As the vote neared, Hegseth's fate seemed to rest in the hands of a few key figures within his own party, underscoring the deep divisions that have defined this nomination.
With the vote scheduled for Friday, it was clear that Hegseth’s confirmation would be a hard-fought battle, reflecting the broader ideological and partisan divides within the Senate. While his supporters have rallied behind him, praising his military experience and leadership potential, the controversies surrounding his personal life and past actions left many with reservations. The outcome, expected to be close, will be a testament to the ongoing struggles within the Republican Party as it continues to grapple with questions of leadership, character, and accountability.
Login