A Tale of Two Managers: Milwaukee’s Pat Murphy and Cleveland’s Stephen Vogt Shine Bright in Their Debut Seasons
Taking over the reins of a successful team is never an easy task, yet both Milwaukee’s Pat Murphy and Cleveland’s Stephen Vogt managed to not just fill the shoes of their predecessors but leave a legacy of their own in their debut seasons. Their outstanding performances earned them the highest managerial honors in baseball, showcasing their natural leadership and knack for bringing out the best in their players.
Stephen Vogt: A Star in the Dugout
At just 40 years old, Stephen Vogt has already made history. After a mere two years removed from his playing days in the majors, Vogt stepped into a challenging role as Cleveland’s skipper and exceeded all expectations. In his first season, he guided the Guardians to an impressive 92-69 record, claiming a division title and securing a spot in the AL Championship Series. His Guardians ultimately fell to the New York Yankees in a competitive five-game series, but Vogt’s leadership left a lasting mark.
Vogt’s rapid rise from player to manager is nothing short of remarkable. He’s the fastest in history to make the leap and win Manager of the Year honors in just two years, surpassing Joe Girardi’s previous record of three years when he won with the Florida Marlins in 2006. Vogt’s journey is a testament to his deep understanding of the game and his ability to connect with players on a personal level.
“I got way more excited when any one of our guys hit a home run than I ever did myself,” Vogt shared. “That’s the beauty of this role—it’s not about you. It’s about your players and their successes.” His humility and player-first mindset have endeared him to fans and his team alike.
Pat Murphy: A Lifelong Journey to the Top
On the other side of the league, 65-year-old Pat Murphy took a very different path to his managerial success. A seasoned coach with decades of experience at the college level, Murphy transitioned to the professional ranks in 2010 after a storied career at Notre Dame and Arizona State. After spending time in the San Diego Padres’ minor league system, he joined the Milwaukee Brewers as a bench coach in 2015 under Craig Counsell.
When Counsell unexpectedly departed for the Chicago Cubs in the offseason, Murphy was handed the opportunity of a lifetime. The Brewers placed their faith in him, and he delivered in spades. Milwaukee finished the season with a stellar 93-69 record, clinched the NL Central title, and made the playoffs. Although the Brewers were eliminated by the New York Mets in the Wild Card Series, Murphy’s efforts did not go unnoticed.
“I just didn’t want to let the Brewers down,” Murphy said. “From the ownership to the players and coaching staff, I wanted to be prepared and advance the needle a little bit.” His dedication paid off, earning him the National League Manager of the Year award, the first in Brewers’ franchise history.
Making History on the Biggest Stage
Both Murphy and Vogt’s achievements were celebrated by their peers, players, and fans across the league. Murphy received 27 of 30 first-place votes from the Baseball Writers’ Association of America (BBWAA), outpacing San Diego’s Mike Shildt and New York’s Carlos Mendoza. Vogt mirrored that success, also garnering 27 first-place votes to surpass Kansas City’s Matt Quatraro and Detroit’s A.J. Hinch for the American League honor.
For Vogt, his victory places him in elite company as just the third Cleveland manager to win the award. He joins legends like Terry Francona, who won three times (2013, 2016, 2022), and Eric Wedge (2007). Reflecting on his predecessor, Vogt acknowledged the big shoes he had to fill. “I knew I had to come in and be myself,” he said. “I could never replace Tito or fill his shoes. I just wanted to help our players be as good as they could be, and that was the goal from day one.”
Competition Across the League
The competition for the Manager of the Year awards highlighted the league’s depth of managerial talent. Carlos Mendoza, in his first season with the Mets, guided the team to an 89-win season and a deep playoff run that ended in the NL Championship Series against the eventual World Series champion Los Angeles Dodgers. Similarly, Mike Shildt led the Padres to a 93-win season and a playoff berth, continuing his tradition of success after winning the award in 2019 with the St. Louis Cardinals.
In the American League, Kansas City’s Matt Quatraro orchestrated an incredible turnaround for the Royals. After enduring a 106-loss season the year before, Quatraro’s leadership led the team to an 86-76 record and a Wild Card Series victory over Baltimore. Although their postseason journey ended in the Division Series against the Yankees, the Royals’ resurgence under Quatraro’s guidance was nothing short of extraordinary.
Detroit’s A.J. Hinch also deserves credit for his team’s late-season surge. Despite losing key players like Jack Flaherty at the trade deadline, the Tigers clawed their way into the playoffs, showcasing resilience and strong leadership.
Looking Ahead
As the league looks to the future, Murphy and Vogt’s success stories serve as inspiration for aspiring managers and players alike. Their unique journeys—Murphy’s decades-long climb and Vogt’s meteoric rise—highlight the many paths to success in baseball.
The Brewers and Guardians are now firmly positioned as teams to watch in the coming seasons, led by managers who understand not only the game but also the importance of fostering a winning culture. Fans can’t wait to see what these two exceptional leaders have in store for 2024 and beyond.
In the end, it’s clear that Pat Murphy and Stephen Vogt didn’t just take over their teams; they transformed them. Their dedication, passion, and unwavering belief in their players exemplify what it means to lead at the highest level. For baseball enthusiasts, their stories are a reminder that success is as much about heart and hustle as it is about strategy and stats.
Login