The New York Yankees recently held an in-depth meeting with Juan Soto on Monday, and according to an industry source, the results left the team feeling optimistic about their chances of locking down the slugger for a long-term contract. Though no formal offer was made during the hours-long discussion, owner Hal Steinbrenner and his top brass walked away from the face-to-face meeting feeling encouraged. They believe Soto is seriously considering a future with the Yankees, and the door is wide open for further negotiations—especially those centered around the financial aspects of a potential deal in the coming weeks.
Steinbrenner wasn’t alone in this crucial meeting. He was accompanied by the Yankees' president, Randy Levine, general manager Brian Cashman, manager Aaron Boone, and senior advisor Omar Minaya. Together, they took turns speaking with Soto, underscoring the strong bonds he’s built not only with his teammates but also with the fans and the city itself. It was clear that they wanted Soto to feel that the Yankees’ organization is a place where he can continue to thrive and where his presence is valued.
Soto, who was sitting alongside his agent Scott Boras, expressed his thoughts on the Yankees’ future trajectory. At the heart of their conversation was a key question: Does the team still have a commitment to excellence in the years ahead? Soto, a player accustomed to high expectations, sought reassurance from Steinbrenner that the Yankees were actively planning to bolster their roster and remain competitive. In response, Steinbrenner made it clear that roster upgrades were on the horizon. However, the specifics of who the team might target in the offseason remain under wraps for now.
While much of the meeting was filled with broad, abstract discussions about the future, the Yankees were eager to understand how Soto felt about his experience in pinstripes throughout the 2024 season. Despite the growing list of suitors for the outfielder’s talents—now including the Philadelphia Phillies—the Yankees are determined to believe they hold an advantage in the race for his services.
As one source within the industry put it, the negotiations are about more than just the money. Sure, financial terms will be a significant factor, but they are not the only thing that matters to Soto. The Yankees made their pitch with a focus on the intangible elements that make playing in New York a unique experience. They reminded Soto that the team had brought him to the World Series, even if it felt more like Soto was the one carrying the team there. Moreover, Soto had the opportunity to enjoy a summer alongside one of the likely MVPs of the season, Aaron Judge—a relationship that seemed to have resonated with the power hitter.
On top of that, Soto’s popularity with fans, especially the die-hard Bleacher Creatures, made it clear that he was already a fan favorite. The Yankees are aware that Soto has created a bond with the city and the team, which could give them an edge when compared to the other interested parties. However, there’s a serious challenge in matching that pitch with enough cash to fend off competition from teams like the Mets, who have made headlines with an eye-popping reported offer of $660 million from owner Steve Cohen.
Despite the large financial offer from the Mets, Steinbrenner remains resolute. One source close to the situation claims that the Yankees’ owner is "100 percent committed" to competing with the Mets’ deep pockets, and he’s prepared to put up a serious fight to keep Soto in the Bronx. The competition, however, is fierce. In addition to the Mets and Phillies, other teams like the Los Angeles Dodgers, Boston Red Sox, and Toronto Blue Jays are also reportedly in pursuit of the talented slugger.
Boras, the agent representing Soto, is expected to wrap up the initial round of talks before Thanksgiving. After that, it likely won’t take long for a decision to be made. According to one insider, Soto could make his choice by the first or second week of December—just in time for the Winter Meetings in Dallas, which will take place from December 9 to 12. This event would provide the perfect stage for Soto to announce his new team and, potentially, a record-breaking contract that could set the baseball world abuzz.
The Winter Meetings are a prime opportunity for Boras to unveil Soto’s future in front of a captivated audience of media, executives, and fans. Soto is known to enjoy the spotlight, and this could be a moment for him to shine in front of the world. It’s not just the potential financial windfall that draws the Yankees to Soto; it’s also his proven ability to handle the spotlight and thrive in a high-pressure, high-expectation environment. Unlike some free agents in the past, Soto has already demonstrated that he can thrive in New York’s massive baseball market, handling the attention and pressure that comes with wearing the iconic pinstripes.
This is in stark contrast to other players who have struggled under the intense spotlight of New York. The Yankees don’t want to repeat past mistakes with players who have faltered in the Bronx, such as Joey Gallo, Aaron Hicks, or Josh Donaldson, all of whom had difficulty adjusting to the city’s demanding fanbase. Soto, however, has already shown that he is more than capable of withstanding the pressure of New York’s unforgiving media and passionate fanbase, and that gives the Yankees confidence that he is the right fit for their long-term vision.
While the Mets can also try to appeal to Soto’s love for the Big Apple, they face an uphill battle. After all, the Yankees are just as entrenched in New York’s baseball culture as the Mets, but they have a far larger national following. Yankees fans are spread across the country, and that’s something Steinbrenner will likely use as a key selling point. If Soto truly wants to make a name for himself as one of the game’s greats, staying with the Yankees could offer him the national platform he craves. That’s a powerful argument, and it may be enough to sway Soto’s decision in the Yankees’ favor.
Of course, it’s still early to determine whether the Yankees’ pitch was successful in convincing Soto to stay with the team. But if first impressions count for anything, the Yankees seem to be in a strong position. As the offseason continues to unfold, the Yankees will no doubt continue to press their case, hoping that Soto’s bond with the team, the fans, and the city will be enough to ensure his future in pinstripes. The coming weeks will be pivotal as Soto weighs his options and considers the financial and personal aspects of his next big move. The Yankees are ready, and they’re optimistic that they’re ahead of the competition, ready to make Soto the centerpiece of their future.
Login